Roy Keane has urged Manchester United's supporters not to get carried away after Michael Carrick masterminded a derby win over Manchester City, saying the former midfielder should be judged after a few months at the helm.
Carrick's second stint in charge of the Red Devils – after a three-game spell in 2021 – began in dream fashion on Saturday as United beat City 2-0 at a buoyant Old Trafford.
Second-half goals from Bryan Mbeumo and Patrick Dorgu got the job done, while United also hit the woodwork twice and had three goals disallowed for offside.
United accumulated 2.03 expected goals (xG) to City's 0.45. Only against Brighton in August (2.3) and Newcastle United in November (2.24) have Pep Guardiola's men given up a greater xGA figure in the Premier League this season, while Saturday's -1.58 xG differential against City was their greatest in the competition this season.
Before the game, Keane was highly critical of United's approach to hiring former players as coaches, quipping that Darren Fletcher – who served as interim boss for their previous two games – could not dress himself without asking former manager Alex Ferguson for advice.
And speaking in his role as a pundit for Sky Sports after full-time, Keane joked: "Give him what he wants! Sign the contract!
"Let's judge it over the next few months. The key for him is trying to get momentum in the team.
"He is an English coach; the English media will be pushing for him. He has done well today, but let's see how he does.
"They've won one game! The last manager won more than one game. He's only been there three days."
While impressed by United's performance, which came after Carrick stuck with the four-man backline adopted by Fletcher, Keane pointed out that they were fortunate to keep 11 men on the field following Diogo Dalot's high challenge on Jeremy Doku in the 11th minute.
"Darren Fletcher changed the formation, but there were players missing," Keane noted.
"Michael Carrick has come into the dream scenario. Everyone is available, City at home, they've been a little bit off it, he could have had a man sent off.
"Good timing and a bit of luck, and they have made the most of it. Take nothing away from him – but everyone just calm down."
United visit Premier League leaders Arsenal next Sunday, with City now requiring a favour from their neighbours to revive their flagging title hopes.
dahalnopuy
0
Thank you God! Everyone was exceptional in this team today, solid attitude and determination, creating, attacking, defending. Neutralizing their attack from the beginning, not letting their defense create their play, had them against the ropes! Believe, Believe I said more than a week ago, let United play their game. Shame on Paul Scholes that said "Halland will carry Martinez with him and toss him against the net while he scores", you know what Paul! This why you are only a soldier, you carry orders, you do what your superior tells you what to do, you will never be a Leader the one that makes the decisive decisions, go on and hide behind your microphone, Keane you too take notes, Loud Mouths. In the words of the great Charlie Daniels.... " That's how you play the Violin Son"!!!!
piaabcdoty
1
you talk too much and with jealousy, that's why you are growing rapidly older with gray hair
Lucindayu
1
Why Keane hate United so much, everything about him is negativity and criticism. It look like he want evey manager to fail at United.
fehailotz
1
If a man united manager doea bad, keane wil be the 1st person to slam the manager, not giving him time watsoever.but if 1 does well, then keane goes around wanting to judge only after next few months.this guy is no club legend.hes just a bad smell.
fehailotz
1
stfu keane.always negative.
Kuabcerty
1
this useless kean, this man really need man united down fall
bbs
0
Keane can’t help himself….
ciucikprz
2
agree
hocdikmnry
0
what is Arsenal draw Manchester United beat Nottingham forest Liverpool lost to Nottingham forest 🥰🙆
samprass101
0
captain Roy Keane 😂😂😂. they shouldn't oo 😂😂
Cekabcpsy
0
So it's true that Roy Keane is undoubtedly a generational fool? This dude called Roy Keane is a complete disgrace to his family, the society, Manchester United football fraternity and the entire mankind 💔💔💔💔😭😭😭😭 It's a pity you had wore a United's jersey, and even captained the team in the past 💔💔💔💔💔
zotanoty
1
Kudos, Carrick.
Kinetics231
2
Keane and Neville are two legends I hate to hear. They are both failures as coach
buhaknotuy
0
so what does this fuckin guy want... stupid man
suueklnpty
1
Keane🤣🤣just go away please relax take a chill pill
Habmorty
4
Roy Keane is such a hater
Munikptyz
2
ooh 😮😮 so we shouldn't celebrate 💐 again Mr.know More Kean?
Zecbeirtuz
3
selfish Keane he is jealous of carrick the always took shit about our team
Mizbelnstz
2
Kudos Man Carrick.
Rhema10
4
oga dont tell us to calm we aren't calming anything. we are going with this energy for the rest of the season and beyond
Davichi
5
It's true we need to wait for some time to see how the team progresses in order to judge what Carrick is bringing to the table. However, we don't want to hear it from hypocrites like Keane Neville or who judged him before he even got the job.
Feubklmpru
0
Utd so called legends are idiots. They think that for their legacy to be preserved, the team should continue failing
you are right. first person to say the right thing in comment section. ✌
Zaeelnpu
0
we need to take this guys Keane and Neville to the court why always not talk good on united mtseew rubbish
πLumzy
0
roy keane is a typical product of a premature ejaculation
Tocilostyz
0
Roy Keane is talking out of shame, can't he just keep quiet
AFerkoBa5699
1
That wasn’t luck at all that was clear domination 💪💪💪💪😡 The guy be talking like he wasn’t watching the game
Florence23
0
I hate these two guys they are always negative.
Napbdnry
1
Jealousy legends
Mirgod
0
they don't really want anyone to succeed .. Eventually a revolutionary Coach will take over and they will be history.
UjoAbx
0
Kane should be away from football for a long time ago, everything he said was just his personal, I doubt he watched this UTd game thoroughly, UTD won with 5-0, fa decided 2-0, he got no words for that, pathetic clown, just go away you not doing anything good
vambekrsuz
0
Chelsea are behind Utd and Utd beat you. Therefore if we are average, Chelsea are garbage then[Crylaugh][Crylaugh][Crylaugh]
let's wait and see but average united is already out with no silverware hope, what a tragedy!!!
vambekrsuz
0
calm down after a fluke win, meanwhile manu season is already over, midway into the season, what a club!!!
don't be myopic, beating Chelsea with a man down does not erase the fact that manure season is over already midway into the season, manu is an average team.
Feucnrsz
0
but unlike manure, our season isn't over yet, we are hopeful of a silverware, even the carabao cup isn't decided yet, we are in a better place than your average team
Chelsea are behind Utd and Utd beat you. Therefore if we are average, Chelsea are garbage then[Crylaugh][Crylaugh][Crylaugh]
Feucnrsz
2
Utd so called legends are idiots. They think that for their legacy to be preserved, the team should continue failing
Vobcdlmoz
0
Sholes, Neville and Keane are negative and jealously..
Rangarirayi
0
for what and for who?
Vobcdlmoz
1
don't like negative comments from ex players of united. Gary Neivel, Paul Scholes, Keane...all negative
akshayyy
0
but unlike manure, our season isn't over yet, we are hopeful of a silverware, even the carabao cup isn't decided yet, we are in a better place than your average team
haha how high you are...you are not going to get any silverware this season...wake up from your dream man...
vambekrsuz
0
calm down after a fluke win, meanwhile manu season is already over, midway into the season, what a club!!!
reality check, know ur place
Saueklmz
0
calm down after a fluke win, meanwhile manu season is already over, midway into the season, what a club!!!
talk or no talk we are united
academy1
2
Carrick is a breath of fresh air after the Amorim disaster. Coaches on a temporary assignment always do well. As soon the position becomes permanent, it will be a different story. Good luck to Carrick, he deserves it
Decbcdisu
1
keane whatever he calls himself is a hater and jealousy
beddilnotu
4
We will not calm down, when we lost to Grimsby we suffered so today we beat city with a clean sheet, lets us enjoy fully
vambekrsuz
0
calm down after a fluke win, meanwhile manu season is already over, midway into the season, what a club!!!
but unlike manure, our season isn't over yet, we are hopeful of a silverware, even the carabao cup isn't decided yet, we are in a better place than your average team
ZionHag
1
calm down after a fluke win, meanwhile manu season is already over, midway into the season, what a club!!!
Bcos Chelsea can win the league or maybe the UCL or the League Cup where u head to Arsenal with a 3-2 deficit..well maybe the FA cup.. time will tell.. for now ure a point behind United on the log
Melusisibs
0
Someone should through these apples they are smelling bad i think they are rotten
vambekrsuz
1
calm down after a fluke win, meanwhile manu season is already over, midway into the season, what a club!!!
AFerTXwT4048
1
Tnz
buecdlmruy
1
Gg mu
Immaculate003
3
Let Keane apply for the managerial job and let us see how it goes for him