Gary Lineker has claimed that Gareth Southgate is 'insulting' his England players with his comments on Kalvin Phillips.
Southgate has received widespread criticism for his side's performances so far at Euro 2024, with England picking up four points from their first two matches but struggling to assert their dominance in games.
After narrowly beating Serbia, the Three Lions held on for a draw with Denmark in their second match at the tournament, leaving fans and pundits scratching their heads over why the team is struggling.
Following the Denmark draw, Southgate told the media that his side have been struggling to replace Kalvin Phillips, a player who had been a regular for Southgate until he was dropped from the squad before the tournament.
Speaking on The Rest Is Football, Lineker slammed the Three Lions boss for his comments, insisitng it was wrong for him to have made them.
'It's insulting to some of the players that are there, and also it's wrong,' Lineker began. 'There are players in that squad that could do it.
'Even the young players he's brought, in, Adam Wharton could do it. Kobbie Mainoo could probably do it. Bellingham could play.
'The players just need instructions, players need to understand what their jobs are.'
Lineker's co-host Alan Shearer was in agreement with his fellow former England forward, also taking exception to the comments made by the England manager.
'If we've been relying on Kalvin Phillips for the last however many years, then that is very worrying to me,' he said. 'I didn't understand his comment at all.'
Lineker added: 'That was very strange. Inside he will be sick.'
Phillips was crowned England's player of the year in the 2020-21 season, but his performances declined when he joined City in the summer of 2022 and he endured a nightmare spell on loan with West Ham last season.
Often coined the perfect partner for Declan Rice, the midfielder didn't start a game for the Three Lions at the 2022 World Cup with Bellingham partnering the Arsenal man in midfield and Mason Mount playing ahead of them in three games and Jordan Henderson introduced for the last two.
Southgate said post-Denmark of Trent Alexander-Arnold: 'He's had some moments where he has delivered what we thought he would.
'We know it is an experiment and we don't have a natural replacement for Kalvin Phillips, but we're trying some different things and at the moment we're not flowing as we'd like, that's for sure.'
Pundtis and fans have blasted the comments since, with Lineker the latest man to question the words.
Ian Wright, speaking on ITV, had said: 'Listening to Gareth, he mentioned about Kalvin Phillips and he's the only one in the country who can play that role, I don't believe that.
'I believe Adam Wharton can play it. I think Kobbie Mainoo can play it as well. You've picked them. Now we're in a situation where it's not desperation because we've got four points, but we're in a place where we need something different, we need to change something.'
Phillips was available for selction this tournament, but Southgate opted not to take him to Germany, with his last cap coming seven months ago.
The England boss added that his side have been looking for a midfield solution 'for seven or eight years' and hailed Declan Rice as the saviour of the area of the pitch for his side.
Alexander-Arnold has played in the position for the first two games in Germany, but has been taken off for Conor Gallagher both times, suggesting the 'experiement' is all but over.
Wharton, Mainoo and Gallagher represent the other options for Southgate in the position, while, like Lineker, other have suggested that Bellingham could drop back from the No 10 role.
The Champions League winner has been playing further forward to get him closer to goal, but cries for him to drop deeper have arrived to solve more than one issue.
While it would help find a partner for Rice, it could also potentially allow Phil Foden, who has also struggled in Germany, to play centrally, or mean Cole Palmer could be introduced to the side.
Lenceiopu
0
He's cooking excuses before elimination when the solution is already in his hands. Alexander-Arnold partnering Rice in midfield is a failed project bring Mainoo,Callagher, Wharton or Drop Bellingham to number 8 position while Palmer or Foden take up number 10 position
AMNAJOTH
0
The team is lacking leadership, and motivators, like FRANCE and KANTE despite playing in Saudi Arabia, they should have Milner or Henderson. remember form is seasonal but CLASS is PERMANENT. these ENGLISH kids are struggling with the LEADERSHIP of KANE who has 0 TROPHIES. I can sense Early ELIMINATION if they continue like this.
[image]
What did they achieve when those you mentioned were in the team??
cj1
1
This guy's boy lacks leadership skills, have Henderson and James miler in ur squad. It doesn't matter their clubs what they possess matters just like Kante from Arab league.
Zemadeirsy
0
England builtup play is slow and players are static in their last 2 matches.
KDecency
0
England team will exit Euros through the South Gate.
[Crylaugh][Crylaugh]
lukikmnrsz
2
England team will exit Euros through the South Gate.
wekacmprz
0
He’s still going to start Arnold in midfield just as he usually does with Henderson 😂
Kiweiksy
1
why palmer with no minutes and u talking about experimemt.
Xander3
1
Good for England, you like criticizing others a lot
k52
1
I have said about this manager on countless occasion that England's problem is their manager and he should have shown exit gate long ago. I personally believe that this english side is having very talented players in each and every department but because of this callous manager the team's performance always found wanting.💙 💙⚽
Kunkunmaster
2
starting Arnold in No 4 position is already an insult ....
Akildycee
3
south is trying to cook Rice and stone together but walker walk with Kane on his hand to wipe him, don't you see your experiment does not work 👍
tanbdortyz
0
problem with England is their manager .
Zeabckorty
1
very true, mainoo and warthon are on the bench and they're better players than Philips.
SammyEdema
0
Southgate is trying to cook Rice, Stones and JohnWalker altogether, I don't know how it will taste like
jendknosuz
0
The coach is the problem. It seems like he doesn’t know why he got some players in his team.
siddimtu
2
you take Saka and Palmar who doesn't know how to play cup matches and leave Rashford out and you want to win cup
Cembcklops
0
this is why Southgate isn't good for England, Southgate should not in England team anymore. useless English coach and manager same goes to English referees.
topaimstuy
1
The team is lacking leadership, and motivators, like FRANCE and KANTE despite playing in Saudi Arabia, they should have Milner or Henderson. remember form is seasonal but CLASS is PERMANENT. these ENGLISH kids are struggling with the LEADERSHIP of KANE who has 0 TROPHIES. I can sense Early ELIMINATION if they continue like this.
[image]
very true 👍
topaimstuy
0
he is not a coach..a coach knows what to do if his players are not performing..England don't deserve a coach like him
well said.
KeronKush
2
I've never rated Phillips as a top tier midfielder. Sureky Mainoo is better than Phillips ever was.
Bouaeiosuy
0
Southgate is suffering of trying to accommodate all his star players in the starting lineup, he must sacrifice some big names to balance the team
fuubdelmny
1
Philips is his son inlaw
Yawbcklnps
1
Is Gary Southgate a COACH or a COUCH
Onesmuschialo
4
The team is lacking leadership, and motivators, like FRANCE and KANTE despite playing in Saudi Arabia, they should have Milner or Henderson. remember form is seasonal but CLASS is PERMANENT. these ENGLISH kids are struggling with the LEADERSHIP of KANE who has 0 TROPHIES. I can sense Early ELIMINATION if they continue like this.
ciwanprstu
3
he is not a coach..a coach knows what to do if his players are not performing..England don't deserve a coach like him
tutekntuz
0
Mugu coach
Richardoghale
1
Southgate is not good at all 🤦🏽♂️
zewceilps
4
if he knew that Philippe was good why did he not call him up