Manchester City are already set to face sanctions from the Premier League pending an appeal, but it appears that a number of rival clubs are readying legal action against them
Rival clubs are now queueing up to take legal action against Manchester City.
And it could result in clubs ganging up together and join a class action as they seek huge damages after City were found guilty of breaching Premier League spending rules.
Arsenal, Manchester United, Liverpool and Tottenham reserved their right to sue with legal notices beyond the statute of limitations had passed.
But the nature of the 40 page legal document published by the Premier League showed the depth of the case against City and also opened the door to clubs taking action.
City were accused of making “sham” contracts, were accused of inflating £900m worth of deals and “widespread” deception and the allegations of fraud means there is more scope to backdate actions.
Clubs could sue for damages after missing out on a Champions League place, teams who were relegated could argue they would have survived in 18th place and also on commercial deals.
Sports barrister Yasin Patel, of Church Court Chambers, said: “Four teams have stated they will take legal action but other teams are likely to follow suit.
“In 2013-2014 and 2014-2015, Norwich and Hull finished 18th respectively. They could argue that, had the Premier League taken action, they may not have been relegated. This is a complex argument, but it illustrates how some clubs may seek compensation.
“If these two clubs were to make this argument, it could be said that Manchester City should not have to pay both as only one could possibly have benefitted had City been ultimately relegated.
“The clubs would have to prove that Man City’s alleged actions caused them to ultimately suffer losses due to relegation and the financial implications that followed.
“It would probably be easier for teams who were relegated to make this argument collectively rather than individually.
“The teams could also turn their wrath on the Premier League and argue that if they had done their investigations and subsequent hearings more expeditiously, then Manchester City would not have been able to continue in their actions.
“Other teams that may take actions could include those who lost out on European football, either because of Manchester City taking a Champions League spot, meaning that they ultimately were outside the European places, or because they missed out on Europe after failing to win cup competitions. In 2010-2011 and 2018-2019 this was Wigan and Watford: they too may seek compensation.”
It has been estimated that Arsenal, United, Liverpool and Tottenham could be in line for £200m each because of damages when it comes to missing out on success, commercial deals and Champions League places.
There is a belief the money will run into “vast sums” especially compared to previous individual cases. Everton were ordered to pay Burnley £35m in damages after Burnley were relegated following an Everton Profit and Sustainability breach.
Patel added: “Damages are hard to predict as we do not know many clubs will seek compensation, nor whether they will seek it solely from Manchester City or potentially from the Premier League as well, allegedly failing to properly discharge its duties.
“Everton were ordered to pay £35million to Burnley in compensation for losses suffered due to Everton’s breach of Profit & sustainability Rules.
“The appeal is due to be heard in January. But that involves just one club. If we have 10 to 15 clubs seeking compensation, Manchester City could be looking at paying vast sums to other clubs in addition to all the legal costs that could follow.”
Richrocky
0
the only thing that matters to me right now is the sanction I just want to hear that they have been relegated to league two and all trophies stripped of their cabinet
You will wait till externality if that what you are waiting for
jeebcmps
1
It's obvious you don't know what you are talking about. Go and find out about your own team, where do you think the evidence came from? It came from City themselves, look up a guy called Pinto from Portugal who leaked it on Football Leaks. City are fucked, not got a leg to stand on.
I couldn’t agree more with your comment .
Big_Dave
1
Haba,Has it gotten to this I heard their lawyer cooked up a 200k files on why Man city is innocent 😂😂😂
Laackmrsuy
1
the only thing that matters to me right now is the sanction I just want to hear that they have been relegated to league two and all trophies stripped of their cabinet
You’re too Good I love your comment God bless you
bizenotyz
0
The problem is not man city it is that the system is over regulated.
Jimadlopsy
1
man city time no matter what yall haters wanna do or say in a real world the epl and super league 3evidence can't hold up. so keep living in yall fake world for now
It's obvious you don't know what you are talking about. Go and find out about your own team, where do you think the evidence came from? It came from City themselves, look up a guy called Pinto from Portugal who leaked it on Football Leaks. City are fucked, not got a leg to stand on.
dapadklty
6
the only thing that matters to me right now is the sanction I just want to hear that they have been relegated to league two and all trophies stripped of their cabinet
Litelntz
0
They have been successful via their illegalities. Now they can try to get out of it. Unfortunately the damage has been done and the punishment has got to fit the crime. That’s the law of the land.
man city time no matter what yall haters wanna do or say in a real world the epl and super league 3evidence can't hold up. so keep living in yall fake world for now
Litelntz
0
yall can come beg that one...one...cause I know it's yall bidding the epl doing but spurs where does these duppy comes from u get brain washed.. but 1thing I have to tell the epl super league 3z yall gotta pay when city wins their appeal we coming at yall
Zitcmnptuz
0
After everything ends Tottenham should also be investigated 🥺
for what?
Wamiklmsty
0
you will be waiting until you just get tired bcous nothing will happen
😂😂. Honestly the epl is as much to blame as City. If they were cheating this should have been taken care of by the epl 10 years ago, then Man City and the epl would not be in the horrible position they are in today. No winners here!
Cisceilmns
2
Epl must punish all clubs that bought players from Manchester city😂😂😂
Liubeknrt
2
yaaa pakashata city yonyura
resabekpst
3
I can see Man Cheaty declaring bankruptcy!
That wouldn’t surprise me at all.
resabekpst
5
They have been successful via their illegalities. Now they can try to get out of it. Unfortunately the damage has been done and the punishment has got to fit the crime. That’s the law of the land.
AbefeWealth
1
non of our business they gonna pay
Zatbcdkmo
3
Man City will regret their action they are cheaters ❤️❤️ I hope they should be restrict their titles Man City did not see anything a lot is coming let wet for January
cuccdiknz
0
Let's wait and what's going on
Wamiklmsty
0
Shamchester City has spoiled the sporting integrity of British Football
Well it has definitely destroyed the integrity of Man City. I wouldn’t lump Liverpool in with them…….even if Isak did defect to them. Still one of the greatest and most respected clubs in football!
kuzemsuyz
0
And too late for Man City! ⬇️⬇️
you will be waiting until you just get tired bcous nothing will happen
Wamiklmsty
2
I can see Man Cheaty declaring bankruptcy!
Wamiklmsty
3
it's too early for this nonsense 😒
And too late for Man City! ⬇️⬇️
kuzemsuyz
0
it's too early for this nonsense 😒
conaceilpy
1
After everything ends Tottenham should also be investigated 🥺
Hiheklosuz
1
seriously you all goes empty hand😁
Yuubilmpsz
0
I saw someone saying saying mancity will be resolved, lolz are you the one to dissolve it ? all these poor performances clubs wanting mancity to be stripped out ,but Chelsea remained calm so far ,see hopless man u,talking when others are talking , Arsenal is happy cos it's mancity who kill them always is now in trouble ,you poor performances clubs should get lost
Mrliberty
3
This is getting serious than I thought earlier 😂😲
CalebKeddie
7
Shamchester City has spoiled the sporting integrity of British Football
hoydeklz
2
mancity will be dissolved. What an absolute dead bags. City free loader.