Manchester United boss Ruben Amorim has been left frustrated by his side's goalkeeping situation, but he may benefit from listening to a previous Sir Alex Ferguson comment
As Ruben Amorim grapples with his goalkeeping dilemma at Manchester United, he could do worse than heed the wisdom Sir Alex Ferguson shared with Sean Dyche. Today, goalkeepers are expected to start attacks and maintain possession with their feet, while Ferguson solely concentrated on how his No. 1s were able to stop goals going in.
Altay Bayindir once more looked shaky during United's 1-1 away draw with Fulham when dealing with the Cottagers' set-pieces. It mirrored his struggles against Arsenal seven days earlier.
Nevertheless, he showcased his distribution skills when he released Matheus Cunha with a thunderous long ball, with the Brazilian's attempt being expertly thwarted by Cottagers keeper Bernd Leno.
Impressive as this was, Ferguson, during a private chat with Dyche after a previous meeting between Burnley and United, insisted the primary concern for keepers should be preventing goals and dealing with crosses, rather than fancy footwork.
Given Bayindir and Andre Onana have both looked uncertain under Amorim, who is reportedly eyeing a swoop for Royal Antwerp shot-stopper Senne Lammens, the United head coach might be wise to follow Ferguson's counsel when making his next goalkeeping call.
Speaking on the No Tippy Tappy Football podcast, Dyche revealed details of a discussion he'd had with the legendary United chief regarding his former Burnley keeper Nick Pope, now of Newcastle. Dyche said: "Different managers want different things. They were questioning Nick Pope, I couldn't believe it.
"They were questioning him about his playing [with his feet], saying, 'Oh yeah, but he can't do this and he can't do that.' Sir Alex Ferguson always invites you up to his room there. When we (Burnley) played United, Nick Pope was playing terrific. I think we drew the game and he was coming out, taking crosses, terrific.
"He was the monster player that he is, great player for me, great goalkeeper. Sir Alex, he said, 'Oh he's a big boy and he does this,' and I said, 'Yeah, they keep going on about his feet.'
"He said, 'Feet? He stops the ball going in the net. People said that about [Edwin] van der Sar. That (ability with his feet) was a bonus. Van der Sar could handle and he could stop the ball going in the net. The rest of it was a bonus.'
"That's old guard by the way, but call it how it is. I'm not going against modern coaching, trust me, I know all the terminology and that's fine. But sometimes the simplicity is, his job is to stop the ball going into the net.
"Brian Clough used to say to his centre halves, 'Head it, and kick it, and give it to someone who is better than you – and that's everyone.' The basics are still the basics, that was Sir Alex's point, and Nick Pope stops it going in the goal."
Erik ten Hag, Amorim's predecessor at United, didn't heed this advice when he splashed the cash on Onana, a keeper known for his footwork and creativity, to replace David de Gea. However, Onana's shot-stopping and handling skills have been found wanting at Old Trafford.
With United said to be nearing a potential agreement over signing Lammens, it seems neither Bayindir nor Onana feature in Amorim's long-term plans. Given the shortcomings of both keepers, the ex-Sporting Lisbon boss might do well to ensure Lammens can handle the basics, much like Ferguson did with Van der Sar.
cocdeikmsz
0
Amorim change your formation to 4-3-3 please
biaeinotyz
1
The problem It's not only goalkeeping position that Man united are facing challenges. Bruno farnandez position in the middle it's not his position. EPL need 2 defensive midfield. not some one like farnandez. Mbomo or Bruno one must be on the bench.
Vicacikmnr
0
og
Bocbenou
1
Amorin out go now
feacempyz
1
Thank you Ferguson I don’t know what Amorim is doing 😪
Ikbest0000
1
Good advice, but their stubborn coach won't listen. I don't see Amorim completing the season at United.
yecabcor
0
first it was da strikers den midfielders den defenders now it's da goalkeepers like I sed last season if U playing 3 in da back it weakens da goalkeeper bcus e is under much stress as da 3 defenders so we can get da best but united will still struggle it's sad dou
luuilnpstu
2
Ferguson's real words: " fix that shit 3-4-3 formation or ..."! Amorim:" yes tomorrow sir"
ArchangelRaphael
1
no need of dropping my comments you have said it all bro
Bokcelmopt
13
A CALL FOR CHANGE: AN OPEN LETTER TO RUBEN AMORIM, MANCHESTER UNITED COACH Dear Ruben Amorim, Forget the fact that you came to Manchester United mid-season and flopped by finishing 15th last season. Yes, we understood and supported you because you have your vision and the kind of players that can seamlessly fit in. The reason we said let the fresh season start is so that you can recruit your players. Now, the management has bought you enough attacking talents in Man United. The midfield is a serious concern, as everyone knows. The attacking line is one of the best three in the EPL if a good coach is in place. The match yesterday, Fulham 1-1 Man United, was largely due to your poor selection. My questions: 1. Does it make sense to bench Sesko, a brilliant striker for a second time, after such a huge investment, and start a makeshift striker like Mount instead? 2. Why can't Amad substitute Mbeumo instead of playing him as right wing-back? Or could Amad play first and get substituted by Mbeumo? 3. Why do you always like Bruno to play 90 minutes when it's obvious he's underperforming? Does being a captain mean you must play 90 minutes? 4. Does it mean Mainoo can't substitute captain Bruno? 5. What's stopping you from adding another talent that can complement Bruno, considering he's now 30 and can't play like he did in the last 3 to 5 years, especially given the physical demands of the EPL? 6. What is so special about Dalot that you like featuring him when most of his plays have flopped? Or is it because he's a fellow Portuguese? 7. Why do you believe only the 3-4-3 formation can work for you? Is it a sin to try another formation like 4-3-3, which is likely to fit the kind of players we have? 8. Do you even realize that playing Bruno as Central Midfield (CM) rather than Attacking Midfield (AM) is wasting his talent? 9. Do you think two midfielders can create chances for you in the English Premier League (EPL)? 10. Why do you always have starting XI selection problems? Up to now, you don't have a complete first team. This raises signs of an incompetent manager. 11. If you know Bruno is unfit for your style of play, and Saudi Arabia clubs are offering around £90m to £100m, why not disconnect those emotional ties and Portuguese solidarity and cash out to enable us to add additional midfielders? Moreover, your pattern requires more physical attacking players, and Bruno lacks it, unless you've changed your style of play. Finally, I'm pleading with the Man United management to get Amorim a good holding midfielder and a goalkeeper before the transfer window closes. After which, if by December 2025, there's no drastic improvement (meaning Man United is not in the top six), he should be axed out of the club, and another coach should come and try. We know transition is a gradual process, but you can't be in a club for almost a year and remain stagnant... THANK YOU 🙏
Danielkelly
3
Good thoughts 💭
dotcdlmrt
4
Good advice. Goalie should stop them going in, period.Just like a striker is expected to score. Anything else is a bonus. Great advice