On May 12th, local time, The Telegraph reporter James Ducker analyzed the movements of Man City players this summer. If Man City can find a buyer for Reijnders this summer and introduce an upgraded replacement at the same time, they may consider selling him.
The following is Part 2
Midfielders
Rodri (Contract until 2027)
The 2024 Ballon d'Or winner had gradually recovered to his best form after a serious ACL injury, but a subsequent groin injury kept him out of the last 4 games, including the costly 3-3 draw against Everton. Real Madrid are considering bringing in the player, but his importance to Man City remains enormous. Losing him in the same summer as losing Bernardo Silva would be a heavy blow. Man City have offered him a new contract.
Conclusion: Stay
Bernardo Silva ( Contract until 2026)
The Portuguese is arguably one of the greatest signings in Premier League history. No player has made more appearances under Guardiola at Man City than he has. Now 31 years old, he will end his nine-year Blue Moon career this summer, and he may be the most difficult of this group of modern Man City legends to replace.
Conclusion: Leave
Nico Gonzalez ( Contract until 2029)
The Spanish midfielder has started sometimes and come on as a substitute under Guardiola, starting only 3 league games since the beginning of the year. Given Bernardo Silva's departure this summer and the uncertainty surrounding Rodri's future, the club must seriously consider how to handle the 24-year-old former Barcelona midfielder, as he also wants to get regular playing time.
Conclusion: Stay
Kovacic ( Contract until 2027)
The 32-year-old Croatian midfielder has been sidelined with injuries for most of the season. He has now recovered, but Man City should consider cashing in if there is a suitable buyer this summer.
Conclusion: Sell
Phillips ( Contract until 2028)
Arguably one of the most failed signings since Abu Dhabi took over Man City. The 30-year-old English midfielder has only played 7 minutes for Man City in the past two and a half years. After joining Sheffield United on loan this February, he has only made 3 appearances due to suspension and injury. He has two years left on his contract.
Conclusion: Sell
Foden ( Contract until 2027)
After two difficult seasons, the English midfielder has agreed in principle to a 4-year contract extension with Man City, which is also the club's firm support for him. His form has picked up in the past week, but the 25-year-old still needs to prove next season that he can regain his peak level.
Conclusion: Stay
Cherki ( Contract until 2030)
One of the most successful signings last summer, it can be described as excellent value. The French organizing core is an important contributor to Man City's return to the title-contending group. He has not only scored many wonderful goals, but also his performance without the ball has improved significantly as the season has progressed.
Conclusion: Stay
Reijnders ( Contract until 2030)
The Dutch midfielder was a regular starter at the beginning of the season after joining from Milan for £46.5 million, but has only started 4 league games since the beginning of the year. If Guardiola leaves, he may usher in a new life under a new coach; but if Man City can find a buyer this summer and introduce an upgraded replacement at the same time, they may also consider selling him. In any case, if he stays, he must improve his performance next season.
Conclusion: Sell
Nipan ( Contract until 2030)
The 19-year-old needs stable game time, and continuing to loan him out next season may be the best option.
Conclusion: Stay (but on loan)
Forwards
Semenyo ( Contract until 2031)
He scored 7 goals in his first 12 games after joining. However, he has only scored 1 goal in the last 11 games, and his form has declined, but the 26-year-old has indeed brought different changes to Man City's front line.
Conclusion: Stay
Savinho ( Contract until 2031)
The 22-year-old Brazilian winger has only started 5 league games this season. He is very close to joining Tottenham, and a transfer this summer may be the best option for all parties.
Conclusion: Sell
Haaland ( Contract until 2034)
He is perhaps the best center forward in the world today. The Norwegian striker signed a new nine-and-a-half-year contract last January and continues to maintain an amazing scoring rate, while having a huge impact on and off the field. This season, he has scored 50 goals in 56 games for club and country.
Conclusion: Stay
Marmoush ( Contract until 2029)
The Egyptian striker has not really played up to his potential since joining for £63 million. Injuries, the African Cup of Nations and fierce competition have limited his opportunities, but the 27-year-old deserves another season to prove himself.
Conclusion: Stay
Doku ( Contract until 2028)
The only 23-year-old Belgian winger is a huge threat to any defense, and he is ending the season in excellent form. Man City are likely to renew his contract, and he may also become a key figure in the Belgian national team in the World Cup.
Conclusion: Stay
Grealish ( Contract until 2027)
Loaned to Everton last summer, but has been out injured since January. The 30-year-old English midfielder is about to enter the last 12 months of his contract with Man City and is expected to leave this summer, either on loan again or on a permanent transfer.
Conclusion: Sell
Echeverri ( Contract until 2028)
The Argentine U23 forward has been on loan at Girona since January. Continuing to loan him out next season may still be a reasonable option for the 20-year-old.
Conclusion: Stay (but on loan)
akpchoichinho001
0
Chelsea give us tijjani
Busaeisu
1
call Man City players they are good for now I think Man City is in phone
Jabacnostu
0
Nope, Reijnders should go. He isn't as good as expected. He can't make any impact in starting 11, neither make any impact coming from the bench. They should sell him, get some fund and buy another good option from the market. You can't compare Foden with Reijnders in City's shirt.
Tesbceikty
0
Yesssssss
1874Villan
1
I saw some rumors that we might pay €70M for him, but I doubt it. Villa and €70M in the same sentence shouldn't exist, hahah, but I think he'll fit perfectly in Unai's system, especially with Rogers, sadly probably departing this summer
I like how you think, but we already have problems with PSR, and a very good player will also ask for a huge wage, and we can't afford it, we need to get rid of the players with huge wages this summer so we won't have any problems anymore. That's why finishing in the top 5 and winning the UEL will be perfect
Boss0987
1
James Ducker, your analysis lacks merit. While Foden may be experiencing a dip in form, your inability to provide an honest evaluation seems influenced by both of your nationality. Reijnders should not be sold as you suggested. Given that Pep has not included him in the majority of line-ups this season, recommending his sale appears misguided.
Siaademsy
3
cherki and reijnders plays a different game .. if they do wanna sell reijnders. Arsenal would definitely fit him, right in zubimedi spot. omar marmush for a left wing/ striker wouldn't be a bad deal either
leuklmnpsu
0
Chelsea should bring him please please
Never
sizintyz
0
get rid of him without even a 2nd thought he hasn't lived up to the Blue Moon(Cityzens) expectations so yeah putting him on sale is the best option
GilpinSambaBazoSh
1
why putting him on sell
wewbikrtuy
0
it is good idea because he is not good enough in City better find good quality player..
Sueabcekt
0
nobody is talking about big signing that have all being flog under Pep
there are good players but not fit in his playing style so he bench them
Sueabcekt
1
No problem with oil money..that bald Pep will be smiling from ear to ear...
oil money won a treple and 4 in a row what did your team won🤣
NobleOT
2
Chelsea should sign Reijnders he’ll fit in our system
MxolisiMM
3
What about vitor ries
raddekmoru
0
2:1 in favor of Arsenal
Kevin201
1
Cherki displaces Reijnders.
Pezbcdmntu
1
The same thing happens to Kalvin Philips...
Kevin201
0
I want him in Barcelona but Barcelona had enough AMs and CMs.
Has*
Kevin201
0
I want him in Barcelona but Barcelona had enough AMs and CMs.
Kayboi1990
2
Not sure about this.
Fumbimopsy
1
up Chelsea 😎
Fumbimopsy
1
Chelsea should sign him up
Fumbimopsy
0
Chelsea should bring him please please
Jezbdkmosz
2
we need teijnders because he has good attacking when the Manchester city needs goal
EAGLECOPPER
2
Man City should not make a mistake by selling Reijdners, he still have potential to improve, if he's in Bayern Munich you'll see his biggest potential
Mazabinprz
0
give him time to prove himself just like nunez
sabbirbhuiyansm
0
🧾
bodieu54
0
this happens when players run go to big clubs
when pep fucks up people's careers*
bodieu54
1
I saw some rumors that we might pay €70M for him, but I doubt it. Villa and €70M in the same sentence shouldn't exist, hahah, but I think he'll fit perfectly in Unai's system, especially with Rogers, sadly probably departing this summer
he's too overrated for yall too, i hope villa will find some good players, villa is a big club with history, emery should find a good number 8 for midfield and decent winger, i was shocked when diaby left
bodieu54
0
nobody is talking about big signing that have all being flog under Pep
tbh people expected more from that dude
bodieu54
0
No problem with oil money..that bald Pep will be smiling from ear to ear...
he's jumping in the summer as well
Mbanoz
2
chelsea should go for this guy
Rinkachi2221
3
No problem with oil money..that bald Pep will be smiling from ear to ear...
Fencdenou
2
nobody is talking about big signing that have all being flog under Pep
1874Villan
2
I saw some rumors that we might pay €70M for him, but I doubt it. Villa and €70M in the same sentence shouldn't exist, hahah, but I think he'll fit perfectly in Unai's system, especially with Rogers, sadly probably departing this summer
Hayabeimnu
2
this happens when players run go to big clubs
josdkmt
0
he should be sold.
josdkmt
1
yes I support