VAR should have told referee Chris Kavanagh to overturn Bruno Fernandes's red card against Tottenham, a panel has found.
The midfielder was sent off just before half-time in Manchester United's humiliating 3-0 loss at Old Trafford after scraping his boot against James Maddison's leg while contesting the ball.
Both sets of players quickly surrounded the referee but, despite Fernandes's protestations, Kavanagh was told to stick with his original decision and the Portuguese had to trudge off down the tunnel.
This week, United successfully had the red rescinded, sparing the 30-year-old a potential three-match ban.
To place further unwanted attention on VAR, the Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel has now ruled that the video system should have intervened in the decision as it happened, the BBC reports.
It wrote: 'Fernandes is reaching, the contact is high but certainly not excessive force or endangering the safety. The evidence is also there for a VAR intervention.
'The panel also felt that the assistant was responsible for leading this decision.'
The group is made up of five members and includes three former players and managers. Also on the panel are one representative from the Premier League and one from the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL).
United were a goal down, courtesy of Brennan Johnson's fourth strike in four matches, when Fernandes saw red and conceded two more in the second-half, with Dejan Kulusevski and Dominic Solanke adding to the tally.
The panel also weighed in on a number of other contentious decisions from a busy weekend of football, including the awarding of a Newcastle penalty after Man City's Ederson fouled Anthony Gordon.
The members unanimously supported the decision of referee Jarred Gillett to give the spot-kick in the early match on Saturday.
Meanwhile, the panel were also in agreement in backing Samuel Barrott's call to not give Arsenal's Riccardo Calafiori a second yellow card in the Gunners' 4-2 win over Leicester City.
The Italian had been booked in the 49th minute and the Foxes wanted him to see red for another challenge later in the half on Facundo Buonanotte.
The panel wrote: 'It's a careless challenge, not reckless, it doesn't stop a promising attack as [Thomas] Partey is right there covering.'
There was room for disagreement, however, regarding Peter Bankes' decision to award Chelsea a penalty in the Blues' impressive 4-2 win against Brighton on Saturday.
Two of the five members sided against the call which penalised Georginio Rutter for a foul on Jadon Sancho and said the Seagulls man was 'entitled to run that line', stating it 'looks worse due to the closing gap'.
muhceilrst
0
that's was a kind of hatred by the ref , I clearly didn't see any touch and dats too bad even the one with Tottenham never had any impact and it was a clear unavoidable accident
Fakbknosuz
0
Heβs now a target. They never love him
Alfatah
1
I think there is something that red card that was given to Fernandez don't forget it's England if Fernandez does not sent off that day I believe another man united player will be sent off though it a politicize ref card to me
Laacenuy
0
i think he deserved it and even am ok bcuz all man u players can focus on there way of playing without looking for him b4 they decide. Bruno is frustrated that's why mostly he just waist ball by kicking it anyhow and ETH is the most useless coach bcuz every time he believes he's right and how talk whenever they ask him questions about the team and mostly blame player except those from Ajax or Dutch family members player.
mopbdiryz
1
Frustration is all I can see on Bruno Fernandez
mopbdiryz
1
VAR needs to be investigated
sudalmntuz
0
he is a fulani man.he has Fulani blood in him.he complains a lots, always claiming to be right.he wants everything to go his way
Kesadlor
5
blame Maddison for his Oscar acting, it was too realistic to fool VAR too
Blinksclinton1997
0
The spirit of badluck just dey small follow this one ππ€£π€£π€£π€£ππ
Kudbcdlmsu
0
utd even played better without him
thank God he got red card. performance was improved after his red card
wimlmpru
0
ban the Ref
gallasyommy
1
After the did has been done π€¦π€¦π€¦π€¦
miadilmopy
0
Bruno Fernandes is so much angry that's why always get red in two matches is because of power of Manchester United have in English league that things against Tottenham is red card aggressive person which him don't like FC Porto
jhkr
3
Now he has got another we have been pleading for premier now its for europa i think its time for bruno to be beached for some few games
Zokdklmn
1
United was robbed, nothing else
ruybimrtuz
0
But tonight he got another one.
Fieirsuyz
1
ni
Vezakmsuyz
1
what about today's match ?πππβ€
DONCLEVER1
1
Fernandes became the Europe highest red card earner of the week.
adedefender
2
Please leave VAR alone, the player himself is useless
kuucdklmps
1
useless, how can the affected teams benefit from this?
Sebiklorsu
3
utd even played better without him
kaodkmnpz
0
Tonight was soft too
bamadiloty
0
Itβs we made sure he got another one today
Youtd4eva
2
Same Shyte Different Day.Today encounter revealed the defensive frailties. ALL Portos goals were soft goals to concede with Utd's defense all to blame. Midfield is dead, no dyanismn, can't rely on the likes of Casimero, Bruno and Eriksen. Maguire is better than Delight
bukai26
2
Two back to back wrong decisions and sending off for the same player. Ridiculous.
wocabdilp
5
Bruno is very stupid
macdimnuz
0
the guy is just tired and needed some resting
and he got another one tonight he just need rest or moreover benching will do
sapdiklort
0
why?
Seobikly
1
Referees trying to get Bruno Fernandes to take some games off π
macdimnuz
2
the guy is just tired and needed some resting
roaacdlu
2
what about his second tonite ?