Ramos is no where compared to best defenders of all time like maldini,nesta and canavaro. To me puyol is better than ramos. Check how many goals barca conceded during puyols era and see that of ramos. Madrid has conceded more goals under ramos than puyol in barcelona
boibrandon
103
2019-10-05 12:11
how can u compare a world class striker , a defender , a penalty specialist and a masterpiece of comebacks with just one defender ? Ramos beats puyol in every aspects,, barca fans know it
lupalmnrty
92
2019-10-05 14:06
Regardless of their personal and collective achievements which Ramos edged Puyol. However, if we even talk about ability or completeness as players, Ramos will still edge Puyol. Ramos is good in the air like Puyol, he aggressive too like Puyol, but he has more on-ball qualities than Puyol. Let's be sincere here and forget about team's loyalty, Ramos has more qualities as a player than Puyol that's why he's the only Spanish player that appeared more in the world best 11.
In fact, according to statistics only Messi and Ronaldo featured in the world IX than Ramos' 10 appearance. Than why waste our time on sentimental comparison when facts are proven?
Arsel123
84
2019-10-05 11:36
Only Madrid fans will say Ramos ! Everyone else knows it’s Puyol ! Puyol was great and had class too ! Ramos doesn’t have class at all ! He dives, spits, abuses all the time and is almost all the time on the receiving end against everyone! Specially he is Messi’s personal Bit** ! 🤗
wetekrsuz
71
2019-10-05 12:48
When Spain had Ramos Puyol and Pique, the CBs were Puyol and Pique. Ramos played fullback. Ramos got the chance only when Puyol retired. Hope that answers the question.
Rammy-Asante
66
2019-10-05 11:24
I beleive this shd be who wants to be a millionaire question. This is very tough, I had to consult professor Google on this one
Ramos ALL TITLES
Titles
1x World Cup winner
2x European champion
4x Champions league winners
4x Spanish champion
3x World Cup participant
3x Euro participant
1x Defender of the Year
2x Confederations cup
3x Uefa Supercup winner
4x FIFA Club World Cup winner
1x Confederations Cup runner-up
2x Spanish cup winner
3x Spanish Super Cup winner
08/09 Primera División Apertura
1x European Under-19 champion
Puyol
ALL TITLES
Titles
1x World Cup winner
1x European champion2008EURO 2008
3x Champions League winner
6x Spanish champion
3x World Cup participant
2x Euro participant
3x Uefa Supercup winner1
2x FIfa club wordl cup winner
2x Spanish cup winnwr
8x Spanish Super Cup winner
So overall I will give it to ramos cos he is a defender who wo go to the extreme to ensure his team gets silverware even if it means playing dirty. And also he has more goals than puyol both at club side and national team. Moreover, ramosnhas 276yellow cards, 22 red cards which puyol won't get even half. This Pic says it all
naelkayyali
61
2019-10-05 10:57
Both are legends and national team team mates and truly leaders . but I well go for payul he has more manners and play always on the ball very rare red cards .
Gunners4ever❤
59
2019-10-05 10:35
Both are great leaders, they marshalled Barcelona's and real madrid's defences robustly for club and done likewise for Spain.
Ramos has scored far more goals than him and won more UCL (4 compared to puyol's 3) and scored some important goals too. It's hard to choose
drstevenson
56
2019-10-05 13:05
Puyol was a warrior and leader..winning every tackle he could . blocking all types of shots..was also good in heading... Ramos has everything Puyol had leadership warrior power headers..winning mentality he never gives up..he goes to CF position in case his team needs a goal badly and scores..yes he's the master of dark arts but all of that is because he ready to do anything to win...Ramos is better for me he has better quality on the ball better passes
Legendar
55
2019-10-05 10:51
They are both equally great as players but Puyol understands his teammates and great leader of his team.
wuhceimnpt
48
2019-10-05 12:10
Ramos tbh would be better in the team. I love Puyol, I just can't choose who's better Ramos or Puyol.
micaryz
39
2019-10-05 11:49
I love puyol as a legend but Ramos get what puyol didn't get, rescue the team when they are down and hopeless, playing dirty and receive cards for the team to get out of danger, puyol played football when defender need to focus only on defense and Ramos is nowadays defender who needs to support the attacks when needed, If I can have both in a team then team will be the best.
kimaceikpu
38
2019-10-05 11:06
Puyol cos he got maturity.I've never seen him fighting or insulting and he's an example of a captain . Ramos is good but he's very wicket and lack the spirit of sportsmanship
jamiinBlaze
38
2019-10-05 10:39
We've seen the end of puyol's career and we know how it looks like, but Ramos to be compared to puyol, and has won everything puyol won and even more, I'll go for Ramos cause he does most things better than puyol. including red cards.
puzabeotuy
146
Ramos is no where compared to best defenders of all time like maldini,nesta and canavaro. To me puyol is better than ramos. Check how many goals barca conceded during puyols era and see that of ramos. Madrid has conceded more goals under ramos than puyol in barcelona
boibrandon
103
how can u compare a world class striker , a defender , a penalty specialist and a masterpiece of comebacks with just one defender ? Ramos beats puyol in every aspects,, barca fans know it
lupalmnrty
92
Regardless of their personal and collective achievements which Ramos edged Puyol. However, if we even talk about ability or completeness as players, Ramos will still edge Puyol. Ramos is good in the air like Puyol, he aggressive too like Puyol, but he has more on-ball qualities than Puyol. Let's be sincere here and forget about team's loyalty, Ramos has more qualities as a player than Puyol that's why he's the only Spanish player that appeared more in the world best 11. In fact, according to statistics only Messi and Ronaldo featured in the world IX than Ramos' 10 appearance. Than why waste our time on sentimental comparison when facts are proven?
Arsel123
84
Only Madrid fans will say Ramos ! Everyone else knows it’s Puyol ! Puyol was great and had class too ! Ramos doesn’t have class at all ! He dives, spits, abuses all the time and is almost all the time on the receiving end against everyone! Specially he is Messi’s personal Bit** ! 🤗
wetekrsuz
71
When Spain had Ramos Puyol and Pique, the CBs were Puyol and Pique. Ramos played fullback. Ramos got the chance only when Puyol retired. Hope that answers the question.
Rammy-Asante
66
I beleive this shd be who wants to be a millionaire question. This is very tough, I had to consult professor Google on this one Ramos ALL TITLES Titles 1x World Cup winner 2x European champion 4x Champions league winners 4x Spanish champion 3x World Cup participant 3x Euro participant 1x Defender of the Year 2x Confederations cup 3x Uefa Supercup winner 4x FIFA Club World Cup winner 1x Confederations Cup runner-up 2x Spanish cup winner 3x Spanish Super Cup winner 08/09 Primera División Apertura 1x European Under-19 champion Puyol ALL TITLES Titles 1x World Cup winner 1x European champion2008EURO 2008 3x Champions League winner 6x Spanish champion 3x World Cup participant 2x Euro participant 3x Uefa Supercup winner1 2x FIfa club wordl cup winner 2x Spanish cup winnwr 8x Spanish Super Cup winner So overall I will give it to ramos cos he is a defender who wo go to the extreme to ensure his team gets silverware even if it means playing dirty. And also he has more goals than puyol both at club side and national team. Moreover, ramosnhas 276yellow cards, 22 red cards which puyol won't get even half. This Pic says it all
naelkayyali
61
Both are legends and national team team mates and truly leaders . but I well go for payul he has more manners and play always on the ball very rare red cards .
Gunners4ever❤
59
Both are great leaders, they marshalled Barcelona's and real madrid's defences robustly for club and done likewise for Spain. Ramos has scored far more goals than him and won more UCL (4 compared to puyol's 3) and scored some important goals too. It's hard to choose
drstevenson
56
Puyol was a warrior and leader..winning every tackle he could . blocking all types of shots..was also good in heading... Ramos has everything Puyol had leadership warrior power headers..winning mentality he never gives up..he goes to CF position in case his team needs a goal badly and scores..yes he's the master of dark arts but all of that is because he ready to do anything to win...Ramos is better for me he has better quality on the ball better passes
Legendar
55
They are both equally great as players but Puyol understands his teammates and great leader of his team.
wuhceimnpt
48
Ramos tbh would be better in the team. I love Puyol, I just can't choose who's better Ramos or Puyol.
micaryz
39
I love puyol as a legend but Ramos get what puyol didn't get, rescue the team when they are down and hopeless, playing dirty and receive cards for the team to get out of danger, puyol played football when defender need to focus only on defense and Ramos is nowadays defender who needs to support the attacks when needed, If I can have both in a team then team will be the best.
kimaceikpu
38
Puyol cos he got maturity.I've never seen him fighting or insulting and he's an example of a captain . Ramos is good but he's very wicket and lack the spirit of sportsmanship
jamiinBlaze
38
We've seen the end of puyol's career and we know how it looks like, but Ramos to be compared to puyol, and has won everything puyol won and even more, I'll go for Ramos cause he does most things better than puyol. including red cards.