Roy Keane has urged Manchester United's supporters not to get carried away after Michael Carrick masterminded a derby win over Manchester City, saying the former midfielder should be judged after a few months at the helm.
Carrick's second stint in charge of the Red Devils – after a three-game spell in 2021 – began in dream fashion on Saturday as United beat City 2-0 at a buoyant Old Trafford.
Second-half goals from Bryan Mbeumo and Patrick Dorgu got the job done, while United also hit the woodwork twice and had three goals disallowed for offside.
United accumulated 2.03 expected goals (xG) to City's 0.45. Only against Brighton in August (2.3) and Newcastle United in November (2.24) have Pep Guardiola's men given up a greater xGA figure in the Premier League this season, while Saturday's -1.58 xG differential against City was their greatest in the competition this season.
Before the game, Keane was highly critical of United's approach to hiring former players as coaches, quipping that Darren Fletcher – who served as interim boss for their previous two games – could not dress himself without asking former manager Alex Ferguson for advice.
And speaking in his role as a pundit for Sky Sports after full-time, Keane joked: "Give him what he wants! Sign the contract!
"Let's judge it over the next few months. The key for him is trying to get momentum in the team.
"He is an English coach; the English media will be pushing for him. He has done well today, but let's see how he does.
"They've won one game! The last manager won more than one game. He's only been there three days."
While impressed by United's performance, which came after Carrick stuck with the four-man backline adopted by Fletcher, Keane pointed out that they were fortunate to keep 11 men on the field following Diogo Dalot's high challenge on Jeremy Doku in the 11th minute.
"Darren Fletcher changed the formation, but there were players missing," Keane noted.
"Michael Carrick has come into the dream scenario. Everyone is available, City at home, they've been a little bit off it, he could have had a man sent off.
"Good timing and a bit of luck, and they have made the most of it. Take nothing away from him – but everyone just calm down."
United visit Premier League leaders Arsenal next Sunday, with City now requiring a favour from their neighbours to revive their flagging title hopes.
Utdw3Stand
1
GGMUSTAR
0
even if Carrick fails but beating City 2 goals plus 2 offside goals is a great achievement for him. Since Ferguson left, who else did this to City? Let's be honest pliz and leave jealous aside.
Carrick is doing well Did you forgot Ole? Pep ass kicker
AFerTXwT4048
0
Tnz b👍
Weoabclmsy
0
Stop Keane being a pundit. Nothing pleases him even when winning. Fault finder at its most.
ZionHag
0
let's wait and see but average united is already out with no silverware hope, what a tragedy!!!
Tell me which trophy we are optimistic to win?
ZionHag
0
don't be myopic, beating Chelsea with a man down does not erase the fact that manure season is over already midway into the season, manu is an average team.
U sound pathetic.. did u start the game with a man down? Why didn’t ur keeper allow Mbuemo to have the change so we can still compete at 11v11? Or United begged Chelsea to get one player out? If u feel United is shit why couldn’t u beat ‘em with a man down… football is facts not fanatism
vubdknptuz
0
hmmmm roy ur woman with big mouth to
pabadiptu
0
even if Carrick fails but beating City 2 goals plus 2 offside goals is a great achievement for him. Since Ferguson left, who else did this to City? Let's be honest pliz and leave jealous aside.
Niudnpsu
2
United player do well give fucker roy keane see u all is done
Niudnpsu
0
Slam roy keane
IA1
0
there is nothing wrong with losing control..
Honabeiklr
0
this kean is just a jealous fool
Luabcikmor
0
You are a big fool! Did anyone withheld your coaching badge? idots called legends
Powabkmuz
0
lets wait and see if Carrick make it top 4 no new manager. Carrick should be given chance to next incharge plus Club should back him with transfer.
Himbcmp
0
You are fu… jealous Keane..mind your business
Cicbcdkst
2
Keane must talk last, hes always criticized players of united yet he no team wants him as a coach and he's a joke he belongs to the circus.
vacbcekmy
1
Kean is always for a man utd coach to have a bad day, so that he can hammer in it. An evil man. We are man utd and we need results and an attacking football
Saeaceistu
1
Piss off
IAmShakur
0
Even John Terry was praising for that performance of the manager, while some so called legends are waiting for bad day of the team to attack. It's very pathetic. We don't care who ever the manager is or what ever criteria u guys sees as a good or bad manager. All we want is good football with winning team.
Did you really follow what he said? He made some solid points and if there's something you disagree with address it specifically instead of just complaining
MadaniAbass
2
Even John Terry was praising for that performance of the manager, while some so called legends are waiting for bad day of the team to attack. It's very pathetic. We don't care who ever the manager is or what ever criteria u guys sees as a good or bad manager. All we want is good football with winning team.
isofadaik87
3
I really don't give a sh¥t about Roy and his buddies' 🐂 sh√t. I've just been given the best weekend in a long time as a Manchester United fan... Arsenal's next.... #GGMU
Motdklmuyz
0
What is this Kaene problem?
KTISK
1
I think Keane is just jealous!
Lazaknpsy
1
well keane and Neville is such big hypocrite when it comes to united its difficult to believe they were heroes of the same team
Lazaknpsy
3
i agree 100% but to have a smile after such a wonderful performance it really put a spark in ones step.0ne game at a time
Tuoadelrs
2
Let's us stop doubting our team and focus on future glory united is doing well at the moment so let us enjoy it and cheer them to victory ✌️🙌 every game. united we stand divided we fall
jedaeklpy
0
get lost Kean jealous people pretend to love united
mrHenphila
1
I understand Keane and angle he's coming from, but let's enjoy the moment, it worth it.
Veddmnopru
1
this Roy Keane has always samething to say useless guy
Alamuolatunde
3
The results are normal.. don’t be carried away! Man united as always showed up against big team. They always put up for derby matches But winning derby matches wouldn’t won you the league if you can’t put up with the mid and small teams in the league. I Ain’t backing up the big mouth guy talk tho.
Carringtonlife
1
We are not carry away but optimistic
Colito
0
those carried away are only from Nigeria and are the same people who cry and rebuke the first 11 before the game starts.
Colito
0
only watched the match until half time. MC didnt want to play to win. just moving the ball around. No midfielders in position.. Thus intentionally allowing MU to attack them. such a boring match. Not as expected. Wasted my money to subscribe. Btw, i am no fan of any football clubs, juat loke to watch a good match...
your age mates are at school football is for adults who reason not you zero football knowledge
Puaaknou
3
Roy is jealous because he didn't get the job so he wanted to destroy everybody who get the job
fancdeimy
0
Roy is spot on with his comment! This team is an absolute joke, they gonna be beaten by a mid or lower table team next week.
Hokdelnoy
1
is Roy keen with us or what look at this one oooo
Willowdd
1
All you idiots beating up on Roy! He actually taking sense you all always get carried away and get you all hopes crushed! Just enjoy the win and hope for the best because you all know this team is inconsistent! And the owners are 💩
Mayhem87
0
Who said this loud mouth raving psychopath Keane guy loves Man United?
zw1Q
1
Maybe Keane is mad that he hasn't been given a chance, why so negative bro?
Venemort
0
thank you Carrick you make us proud
Man u fans go crazy wow win three or four games than you can applaud Carrick
pocabemoy
1
it's time these triplets start putting there big mouths into practice but I wonder who will employ these triplets. roynevillescholes
pocabemoy
4
it's common sense not to get carried away after one game you dont have to be a rocket scientist. Give Carrick credit he doesn't make noise from the studio he is out there proving himself. He is playing Kobie with Bruno i dont understand that other chap kobie must prove himself. good riddance big manager
siybilntuy
3
Congratulations to you Legendary player of all times Micheal Carrick as Man United tactician and God should bless you with more vision , tactics and success⚽🏆🏐🤫🕊🙏🏻🤗❤🌹💖🌍
Sisbcknopr
3
man u fans are fools just one win tails are already in the sky 😭 giving Carrick the job already and making noise Keane is not jealous he is just ryt because he is tired of embarrassment always hyping the coach later, let him be sacked
foudmoruz
2
Keane is not a critic! he's a narcissist who sees nothing good in others Never will I open any report that mentions him
Lepaimpstu
1
thank you Carrick you make us proud
Kogutan
1
That match is no luck..its a solid performance..
Zuaiklpuyz
0
Who is Keane🤣😅
Is a foolish guy
Zuaiklpuyz
1
only watched the match until half time. MC didnt want to play to win. just moving the ball around. No midfielders in position.. Thus intentionally allowing MU to attack them. such a boring match. Not as expected. Wasted my money to subscribe. Btw, i am no fan of any football clubs, juat loke to watch a good match...
What do you mean not as expected, sorry your team lost
Zuaiklpuyz
4
Roy Keane wants this job, he's just jealousy of Michael Carrick.