Manchester United's back-up goalkeeper Altay Bayindir was blasted by Roy Keane for a 'basic' mistake to gift Newcastle their fourth goal on Sunday.
Ruben Amorim dropped Andre Onana after his error-strewn display against Lyon in the Europa League on Thursday night, handing Bayindir his first Premier League start.
But the decision backfired as Bayindir conceded four goals from six shots on target and gave away a cheap final goal in the 4-1 thrashing.
In fairness to the Turkish stopper, this was just his eighth appearance in almost two seasons at Manchester United.
But his decision to try and chip a ball through midfield, which Joelinton intercepted to set up Bruno Guimaraes, left Keane and Les Ferdinand questioning his 'common sense'.
'Of course (he was at fault). You go back to the decision-making. I'm not even sure what the big benefit (would be, making that pass). It's too risky,' Keane said on Sky Sports.
'It's absolutely too risky. There's players around you. At the highest level, it's about your decision making.
'I'm quick to defend goalkeepers when they first come into the team because I think it does take five, six, seven games to get up to speed with the shot. But that basic mistake there, I can't understand it.
'This is big boy stuff. You're up at Newcastle, Newcastle are flying, you do your own homework on who they're playing and when they're pressing you.
'If you're going to go long, make sure you go too far, so then at least it's up the pitch.
'But if you lose it there, someone is through on goal on top of you. That's just common sense.'
Ferdinand added: 'It's typical of what we're watching with goalkeepers noawadays being too precise, too clever.
'Just put your foot through that, say, "we're 3-1 down, let's not go 4-1 down by making a silly mistake." He doesn't, he tries to clip a little dinky ball into the centre-forward.'
'I'm just thinking: "what are you doing?"'
Konarce4christ
0
Roy Keane is an Idiot and has always been since he retired from football, Every player needs time to perform, you can only criticise after being given enough time and no improvement like the case of Onana.
muhceilrst
0
This united legends are being too much on critics,they should just become managers and give us those positive results
StevenKim13
1
these united legends just can't let any small things slide huh, the guy has been on the for how many months
Jtikol10
0
Keep these legends off and let the team play well with mental health! There’s nothing from them more than hurting players mentally
Jtikol10
0
Again Bayindir??? Now fans, legends and the UTD itself are hopeless!!
pipblmpstu
0
Even with Alison in post with this current united squad, Not conceding goals will be difficult.
wiebemnrtz
1
Man united problem isn’t on the field or boardroom. It’s the pundits that constantly keeps talking about them
Bokcelmopt
1
Bokcelmopt
1
Wuoackmnry
5
Please don't criticize the GKs anymore otherwise Amorim will have to field the GK coach...
lazychild226
1
stil i think nowadays too much pressure from social... just think back when de gea stil young,he make alot mistake also... yet SAF trust n support him...we fans also supporting not stress n pressure the players
Zatbcopuz
0
Confused legends, the are the problems of this club , keep using media to pressurize players. Resisted legends . Even in your time you were not the best. Ngemba ngemba was the best at that time , you rally your English brother against him making to loose focus , not given him the right passes , at times not passing him the ball . This are the killers of this club
bimcelopty
1
Blame ETH for all signing last season.
Peyadlst
0
If you don't want Onana, give him to us and take Sanchez.
Subacnptyz
0
this he debut EPL . dont judge only for 1 game . give change another 4.5 games
sirbodmas
2
A Man United fan asked "where is my club ending too ? To all the fans, friends, rivals, enemies and foe. If you know the answer, please tell us, so that I can forward the answer to the fan. Thanks 🙏
sirbodmas
1
From De gea,Henderson,Romero to this bull shit.. Where is my club heading to ???
May be to the promise land of championship
iceyez
1
Both goalkeepers are crap
Peyiklopy
1
yes
Lotckmptuz
0
Bayindi had only 6 shot on target and conceded 4 goals and only 2 saves, what a disgrace, they should get the state of Onana and check the numbers of shots he receives per game, and perhaps his numbers of saves, from they we can compare the best
Lotckmptuz
1
He gave a good assist to his oppenent, what a goalie
Pehabdimps
5
Onanas haters proved wrong
suzadlmpsy
1
Error again?
Jisabeimpt
2
idiot did onana play today? you lunatic
AustinEvergreen1
0
I thought we needed a striker the most until today, A goalkeeper should be top of the list after what we saw today.
jumdnprsu
3
Does it mean without this 3:4:3 formation the coach doesn’t apply any other formation regardless of the approach from the opponent? If yes we’re done because some team needs different approach or formation to beat them
hossanna
3
when you run away because of an error you now fall into the hand of errors
Kuwbiknory
0
Manchester united should've signed Diogo Costa from Porto instead of onana and his making us pay for the mistake of signing him
wowadrsyz
1
are these Manchester united pundits not tired of criticizing their team for the all season. abeg let them just watch bcoz they go criticize tire
BeckMathew
2
De gea is better than the present Man UTD goal keeper both combined
Ronbdemruy
1
please go for Burnley goalkeeper James Trafford
Nxhau
1
from de gea onana now bandiyeer Manchester united must be serious
Wehdnstuy
1
The defending is horrendous...and has been for ages
Hesbelnopz
1
why are U talking about goalkeepers mistake,the whole team including coaching staff made mistakes today.Check those goals
NgoranEmile
6
you've not seen anything...Onana was not even included because you thought he had two blunders leading to goals. United does not have players, don't always blame your goalkeepers for the errors of the infield players.
rahmsey
0
such error is expected of backup goalkeeper. the number one made such, also expect such from his partner in crime.😆😆😆
anurag2255
2
From De gea,Henderson,Romero to this bull shit.. Where is my club heading to ???
pupbiprstz
3
This time is not onana but altay bayindir.. foolish formation from so called coach!
bancknpt
4
I thaught it is only Onana that makes errors????