The Scotland midfielder is now thriving in Italy, where he was the key player in Napoli's title triumph last season.
Speaking on the Overlap, former United captain stated: "What’s happened to Scott McTominay? Have we made a massive mistake?”
Ex-Liverpool defender Carragher replied: “You’ve killed another Man United player, that’s what happened. Too much criticism, (saying) he’s not good enough.”
Arsenal legend Ian Wright then added: “I remember Gary saying they’ve got to get rid of him. Poor Scott. He just wanted some freedom.”
Neville then insisted: “I didn’t say he wasn’t good enough… Not me. Seriously I never thought they should have got rid of him. I always said at the time, he’s a squad player, in the 15 or 16. He should never have been got rid of.”
However, in the past, Neville has claimed: “McTominay, when I watch him, I’m not sure he’s actually good enough on the ball to be a Man United midfield player.
“He’s a big lad. Is he sharp enough on the ball to be a Man United central midfield player?”
KeronKush
4
They make some foolish claims as pundits, then when proven wrong, they deny making such claims.
Cakcdekyz
1
Gary is so bloody stupid.. if he is actually the Man United legend, he should backup Man United players not tell the club to get rid of some players. Even Carragher is not stupid enough to destroy Liverpool players by over critizes.
Nazbdkmsyz
0
I stopped watching or listening to Neville long ago. I've come to the realization that he and many former United players, played a huge part in the demise of the club's image with their constant and unnecessary criticism
Mayhem87
2
First time and last time I ever applaud Jamie Carragher, Gary Neville is 25% of our problems
kbsarpong
0
the 1st time I heard of MacFred was from Gary Neville, Roy Keane, and Scholes all saying they are not good enough to play Manchester United
fuhbklprst
3
how I hate these so called Man United Legends most of them talk rubbish, they seek relevance ..most have failed as coaches.....they should get a life....we have sacked more Manager's than I can count all becoz of the noice these legends make....
lebdknptuy
1
Hahahaha I love what they're telling him
Slimfit15
1
Keep on thriving Scottish Scott
Kadcimnotu
1
Neville don't come here and lie. You and Roy Keane said Mc Tominay can't win anything for Manchester United that they're not good enough to play for Manchester United.
cibcdklopr
0
Neville was 100% right.
twikista
0
All talk but can’t manage himself
Don't mind him
Vukacdkmno
1
Shame on you Gary,you said it
Sovoty
2
They even 4get what they said in the past. They also forget that some criticisms go a long way not just against the players but also the owners of the teams, and the managers who go on to make decisions to get rid of the same players.
pisabdilmz
0
Carragher is doing the same on Salah, it's hard to Wright going hard on arsenal players even when the player is underperforming.....
ZiGGy_CpT
0
true
Kimimstuz
2
He has always been a good player energy, but. tag hag needed somebody to blame for the s***He was doing , and go bay Uglyit no good
Kodcilmnr
0
Scot was always a trier & Mourinho had him in high spirit. Well, always a chance to make it back. I would love to see both Welbeck n Scot back at Old Trafford soon....
Poor Mentality Man U Fans Cmon
PrinceAbobyBlinkz
5
Not only Neville, all the pundits are killing so many players Walai
Matthew14
1
People forget that mctominay was consistently underperforming at United. Mctominay would have never performed the way he has been doing if he still played for United. Same with all the other people that have left and done well. The obvious choice was the sell mctominay at the time.
RedzwanZoraeMUTD
1
loser
Waaclnoru
2
That's very true Neville is very stupid,foolish and senseless
Sieenpst
1
they've done a great job in forcing UNITED sell off good players coz they got the mic 🎤
Vueceimrt
1
if them look back on their career and see the mistake them mek....dem we stop criticise players
bakbirstuy
1
Neville has no shame. He should be hiding his face considering his disastrous stint at Valencia.
All talk but can’t manage himself
Richardoghale
1
which Mc tominay are they singing all about, he doing what he's doing in series A that's his level, he couldn't withstand the pressure in MU, if football is all about goals, am not even seeing him scoring the goal, 15 involement in goals and assists made him world class in Italy, so shameful, he was never the kind of player for MU, stop the rubbish u all are spilling
Big fool
epjo
2
JOSE MOURINHO once said that his my boy remember that the special one
zutbklnsuy
1
Scot was always a trier & Mourinho had him in high spirit. Well, always a chance to make it back. I would love to see both Welbeck n Scot back at Old Trafford soon....
Puscklry
2
which Mc tominay are they singing all about, he doing what he's doing in series A that's his level, he couldn't withstand the pressure in MU, if football is all about goals, am not even seeing him scoring the goal, 15 involement in goals and assists made him world class in Italy, so shameful, he was never the kind of player for MU, stop the rubbish u all are spilling
are you blind or are you a fool
dave2080
0
2 stupid fools
comment agree ,the both re impostors
Heikal_Mahsir
1
Gary is stupid as, always.
robdenrsuz
0
why is Carragher denying...this guy is fond of criticizing many players, he leaves out Liverpool players, shame upon him
zodailz
0
Carragher is dere for Liverpool too he doesn’t hv patience at all
Carragher and Neville are basically two sides of the same coin
twikista
5
Neville has no shame. He should be hiding his face considering his disastrous stint at Valencia.
sammygentle247
0
U guys should better shot ur stinking mouth when things go wrong instead of sticking to the young boy's encourage them to fight more, all guy's does is to add petrol to the 🔥 by critisiziing then just look at Kobi Mainoo I pray they keep him
AFerTGSU7928
2
Exactly especially Jamie carragher
nepckrsuyz
1
stop blaming each other for McTomimay. He is now flourishing high. sometimes we think we know best.
Richardoghale
4
2 stupid fools
returnofthesaith
1
When you don't think deeply before speaking or making unnecessary comments.
Neccklnst
2
these UTD legends are always the problem. There is too much criticism when things aren't going right for the club
Carragher is dere for Liverpool too he doesn’t hv patience at all
BradleyChereni
4
these UTD legends are always the problem. There is too much criticism when things aren't going right for the club
cipbceirst
0
He is best in Serie A no complaints Man U have other options now
cubabcilst
3
Medication after death
snowc2
3
Manchester United taking the advice of an ex coach that failed woefully 😂😂😂
yuwbckopu
6
which Mc tominay are they singing all about, he doing what he's doing in series A that's his level, he couldn't withstand the pressure in MU, if football is all about goals, am not even seeing him scoring the goal, 15 involement in goals and assists made him world class in Italy, so shameful, he was never the kind of player for MU, stop the rubbish u all are spilling
Haybeklory
3
too late he's gone
Ruzairstu
2
man utd legends, want to be the last