Jamie Carragher has urged Manchester United to stick by Michael Carrick despite their poor start to the season.
He insists that Carrick should be allowed the full campaign to restore 'calm' to the club before potentially 'passing the baton' to somebody else.
United have made their joint-worst start to a Premier League season ever with a mere five points from their opening five games, and some concerning performances thrown in.
Gary Neville raised the alarm over what he saw as their 'disgraceful' lack of effort in their 1-1 draw with Fulham at the weekend, but pointed the finger at the players more than his former team-mate.
Now Carragher has thrown his weight behind Carrick, telling The Overlap Fan Debate: 'I think it would be ludicrous to get rid of Michael Carrick.
'I don't see Michael Carrick as the Manchester United manager in the long term. I almost feel like he's in there doing a job for the club to get them through a rocky period and then passing the baton on.
'If that sounds disrespectful to him, I don't mean it like that. He came in, and Manchester United needed calm, they needed not being a circus, not being a banter club.
'His results have been unbelievable since he's come into the job over the long period. He got the job on the back of that. The fact he got them in the Champions League brings the money.
'Manchester United need to be a Champions League club again. It's not about, wow, we're going to win the league this year. They need another season of just making sure you get the Champions League, and then it'd be a case of bringing in one of the top managers about who could manage a club at that level.
'I don't think the idea of changing Michael Carrick now or at the next international break makes sense. It just needs to be relaxed, just let him get on with it.'
Despite a disappointing start to the season, with United 12th in the Premier League, Carrick's overall record with the club is quite strong.
He has won 14 of his 24 matches in charge, drawing and losing five each, and last term guided them to third in the table after taking over from the disastrous Ruben Amorim.
They recently endured a nightmarish seven-day period with three blows: first a defeat to Manchester City in the derby, then a loss to Brighton after throwing away a two-goal lead in the Carabao Cup, then the draw at Fulham where they lacked cutting edge.
Matheus Cunha was only able to score in that game thanks to a wicked deflection off David Affengruber, but they did have 25 shots, which suggests they can be creative.
Neville found the performance abysmal, telling Sky Sports: 'I rarely say teams don't make an effort because that's the ultimate criticism. That first 15 minutes of the second half, and generally the first 60 minutes, United were an absolute disgrace.
‘I’ve watched Man United since the age of five and that's the worst 15 minutes I've ever seen. Absolutely pathetic. I've never seen such a lack of effort.
‘There needs to be a reset in terms of structure. They don't want to do the ugly part of the game.
‘I've never seen a Manchester United team walk as much as that. Michael (Carrick) needs to stop defending them.
'If they carry on like that, they will concede so many goals week after week. They were lucky to concede one.
'I just see apathy and ambling around the pitch. They can all work harder than that- they're getting outrun in every match.'
After Cunha scored a late equaliser – heavily deflected off David Affengruber – to cancel out a disastrous own-goal by team-mate Lisandro Martinez, the forward admitted that United only woke up once Fulham went ahead.
‘In the second half it was like they put in more energy than us,’ he said. ‘We cannot accept this. We always play better after conceding a goal, and it cannot be like this.’
Vowdelmptu
0
sell sell Bruno Fernandes
Vowdelmptu
0
carrick is good but Bruno Fernandes is the main problem of Man utd sell Bruno Fernandes
moceiloprz
1
huh!, that guy has to stay in for at least 3yrs😊
Neubcmopuy
2
this guy he hasn't won the EPL what is he saying
Arjenrobben11
0
United should do the opposite of whatever this prick says
Supadeklsy
0
You might keep on changing coaches, but if you won't rign better players, thunder shall strike again!!!!
MemphisSmith
3
Honestly, from my point of view, Michael Carrick needs TIME. 🔴 I don’t understand how some United fans are already calling for him to be sacked. What exactly are we expecting? Manchester United cannot keep changing managers every time things don’t immediately go our way and then wonder why the club has no stability. Let’s be honest: the manager is not the only problem. The club also needs to properly back the manager in the transfer market. United have a habit of waiting until the last minute to sign players, negotiating over every penny, and then expecting the manager to compete with a squad that may not have everything he needs. If the owners don’t want to spend the money required to bring in quality players, then at least give Carrick the time to work with what he has. You cannot refuse to give a manager the players he needs and then blame him for everything when the results aren’t good. Look at Arsenal and Mikel Arteta. Arsenal gave Arteta time to build his team, even when things weren’t perfect. At the same time, the club backed him with players who fit his plans. That patience gave him the opportunity to develop his ideas and build something. United need to stop starting from zero every few years. Give Carrick time. Back him properly. Give him the players he needs. Then judge his work after he has had a fair opportunity to build his own team. Sacking him now would just be another reset, and I don’t think that solves the bigger problems at Manchester United. If the club really believes in Carrick, then back him properly and give him time. 🔴❤️ We need stability, not another restart.
social3727
2
One thing I understand from these England former players is that they don't like thier selves and now I know reasons they didn't win anything together.
Tobbclnpry
0
don't sack until utd is at 20th place
vaybnpstuz
0
get away who cares for your concerns like u even wish us well centurion idiot 🙄 😉
OsinashiVivian
0
this man you too talk.
GunnArs
0
(for once) neville isn’t wrong…
Badhur
0
This guy is on drugs I’m pretty sure
THEWORM
0
I don't even understand him he said he was incompetent and now he wants him to stay which side are you on
Yaydkmnouz
1
সাজিদ
cumbcipstz
0
Why anticipating sacking? You don't expect a coach to win every match that comes on his way. l think Carrick is among the best after Sir Fugerson. Please maintain him.
vomabklnou
1
You're absolutely right my friend
Thank you Bro
isofadaik87
0
Liverpool doesn’t play alone, and being a fan for Liverpool doesn’t mean you can’t comment on any other teams thank you
You're absolutely right my friend
Vadcilpt
1
Advice from an enemy!
lumlmrstu
0
That's true patient is required let's be patient 🙏 pls
jioabmnprs
1
carick must be given 3 til 4 seassons b/c see Arteta built An Arseanal lake a ston Team we tirted changing manegars so we must believe carrick this man is the man that can built our team we have to give him 4 seassons that is my eyeing
pozbcekmot
0
not 2 months rather the full length of his contract cos he needs more time y'all should learn from Arsenal
correct sir
vomabklnou
1
what about Liverpool can you say something concerning your Liverpool
Liverpool doesn’t play alone, and being a fan for Liverpool doesn’t mean you can’t comment on any other teams thank you
liydimrtyz
0
He cannot reach December. he found wn Amorim had done almost everything for him. He has been with the team for some good time. the levels of intensity have decreased, the team is slow, doesnot hold possession for 2minutes, no building from the back like other teams do ....... carrick has not added anything in the team and he will not. the squad united has, is better to give us good results but the teacher lacks alot. Himself is slow. wat do u expect from the lads.
vomabklnou
3
You wanna enjoy another 2 months of them suffering
Nakcelmny
1
what about Liverpool can you say something concerning your Liverpool
bwalyaalfred024
0
not 2 months rather the full length of his contract cos he needs more time y'all should learn from Arsenal
LilMoneyMoneyMaker
4
🤔For the first time I think carragher had said something reasonable that each and everyone would accept his decision 👍🏻
ndyagumgerald
2
Yes two months I can agree with you but two years no, the guy can't change anything on tatch line. He usually looks to be confused there.
UniverseMan
3
how long arteta get before his maiden epl? carrick must get the same chance too at least
nehbdlrtuz
1
they should allow him more like Ferguson
Voccdekmny
1
the problem of Carrick he want stubborn like Amon , if the system is not working u must change in order to get the results
wubadekoru
0
true he should stay, remember last season we were in the 15th position but we finalized in the third position so let him stay
Lovebug2
3
He must stay like Ferguson. Stingy Ratcliffe is the problem
Sohint
0
Not two (2) Months but two (2) Years, he may succeed in relegating the Team by then 😂
Macbdikmo
0
And they should back him up with players he want
Ancientman
2
On the contrary Carragher, Michael Carrick needs at least two more seasons to build his own squad. Even the Great Ferguson was given enough time to build his own squad.
Nuoabdinp
1
no way he wants Liverpool to give a big gap to united
dapcemnou
1
He can remain. He should work on obvious things, things we see week in and week out. The team plays with zero energy, there is lack of intensity. Martinez and Magure slows down everything etc
Yoyabceipr
0
Well said Jamie Carragher