The easy reaction to Saturday's big game is to say Spurs are big title challengers and City are out of the race. It’s too simplistic. The margins were small, the Spurs gameplan worked but the details went in their favour. If Ederson had stayed on his line they may not have scored at all.
However, there are some conclusions you can draw. Firstly, Harry Kane is in the best form of his life and you can see the work Jose Mourinho has done. Every time Kane dropped deep, there were willing runners for him to find. He looks so strong and physically right.
Other big clubs like Manchester United might have had a chance of signing him a year ago, I don’t know, but I can’t see him wanting to leave now.
He looks the best centre-forward on the planet, he can finish as his club’s record goalscorer and I think he must now believe he’ll win trophies at Spurs.
I don’t think it will be the league this season, they are still too reliant on him, but he looks happy that real progress is being made. He ran City’s two centre-halves ragged yesterday, it was an unbelievable individual performance.
On the flip side, Pep Guardiola has work to do because City’s spine is not as strong as when they dominated. Rodri is a fine player but this game showed he’s no Fernandinho, who missed out with injury and is in the twilight of his career.
People who see the Brazilian as merely a holding midfield player don’t understand his qualities offensively, the ability to make progressive passes, to fire the ball into Kevin De Bruyne.
I saw De Bruyne having to go wide to look for the ball too much. It is part of his game but without Fernandinho, and David Silva, he finds it harder to get service in those central pockets of space. It helps explain why City’s goals have dried up. I didn’t think they would miss Silva as much as they have done but City’s form has shown what boots they were to fill.
Ilkay Gundogan, Bernardo Silva and Phil Foden are very good players but Silva always found a way to create that magic when opponents sat deep and City needed to open them up in pressure situations.
They aren’t as free-flowing or quick this season without Silva or Fernandinho, and you can add Sergio Aguero to that.
Fernandinho is under-appreciated and City need him back. If he’d played against Spurs, no way does Kane get the time and space he did.
You can’t replace Silva exactly but Foden is best suited and I’d like to see him given a run now.
Of course Lionel Messi would improve City, he’d improve any team and make things happen but even if he signed for them, Pep would need Fernandinho back, or properly replaced.
FootballGuru
0
Ederson had a bad game? stop excuses
No excuses here but just watch both goals again how far out Ederson was(penalty spot) and the worst part he was caught in no man's land. The keeper has to be quick to come of his line and has to be sure to reach the ball to tackle or stay on his line a bit longer. After you watch the goals reply to me if i'm right or wrong. 👍
FirstMann
0
Pep is far better than any English premier league manager, so get it in your skull.
no wonder you support Barcelona. a football club were most of the fans sits on their brains. Didn't you read the article before reading my comments? I don't have your time blind fan
Zawbknoru
0
City got lost the day pep preferred rodri above fernandinho
You're on point... Agree with you
Zawbknoru
1
Danny Murphy, I agree with you. Rodri is given much respect that Fernandinho and Gundaguan deserves - he just gives him more playing time. Rodri is a great signing coz of his forward moving mindset, however magnitude of this game needed either a fernadinho or Gundaguan to stop spurs dangerous counterattacks in the midfield. We know that Man city defenders play without much presure whenever fernadibho or Gundaguan play midfield. simply put, Pep should play Rodri in smaller teams, and Fernandinho or Gundaguan in threatening teams like spurs. Pep need to know that he has a capable bench, He should make replacement early when things are not going right. If the replacement pep made could have been done early, goals could have come for city. Big up on Ferran Toures and Dias. great signing!
fizzbizzie
1
if Man United want to donate a Fernandiho like player to city, it should be Matic and not Fred. Matic comes close to Fernandiho more although he is slow
yeah matic is better , he's just aged and slowed
diyilntuz
1
So according to this article Pep Guardiola's signings are all flops. Guardiola can't develop any player. 5 years since singing for city you still Depend on Aguero, Fernandiho, KDB, Silva and Sterling... And since the last man from your inherited team left the defence you are easily blown off in the defence unit. all the players on that field used by Pep Guardiola were signed for atleast 60m so I don't get. Dear Pundits and sport analyst, if Ederson didn't come out and Son scored, you would have criticized Ederson saying he should have came out. I have always known Ederson to come out so often besides the guy is a CDM/Sweeper than a goalkeeper for me. if he hadn't come out the game would have been 5 goals especially the one when son touched the ball too had and went off target. G. Jesus was signed to replace Iheanacho who was decent at the time but he has since been so average and Iheanacho has deprecated. the only players in my opinion that was missed are Aguero and Sane. those guys have a way of unlocking defence. finally who knows Jose Mourinho would have had plans for them too. Reguilion and Hodjberg, are less than 4 month in that club but played really well.
Pep is far better than any English premier league manager, so get it in your skull.
FirstMann
0
which Fred...Fred is not different from Rodri.. they prefer to do the simple things.. Fernandinho was dynamic.. he could dribble , he could tackle, he picked the right passes most times and he never was afraid of risk passing too
if Man United want to donate a Fernandiho like player to city, it should be Matic and not Fred. Matic comes close to Fernandiho more although he is slow
FirstMann
0
So according to this article Pep Guardiola's signings are all flops. Guardiola can't develop any player. 5 years since singing for city you still Depend on Aguero, Fernandiho, KDB, Silva and Sterling... And since the last man from your inherited team left the defence you are easily blown off in the defence unit. all the players on that field used by Pep Guardiola were signed for atleast 60m so I don't get. Dear Pundits and sport analyst, if Ederson didn't come out and Son scored, you would have criticized Ederson saying he should have came out. I have always known Ederson to come out so often besides the guy is a CDM/Sweeper than a goalkeeper for me. if he hadn't come out the game would have been 5 goals especially the one when son touched the ball too had and went off target. G. Jesus was signed to replace Iheanacho who was decent at the time but he has since been so average and Iheanacho has deprecated. the only players in my opinion that was missed are Aguero and Sane. those guys have a way of unlocking defence. finally who knows Jose Mourinho would have had plans for them too. Reguilion and Hodjberg, are less than 4 month in that club but played really well.
riwabiknyz
1
♧pep for removing Fernandinho Fernandinho is far much better than Rodri
kuccklty
0
useless keeper
Elyzclassik
0
Bruno after hearing KDB did nothing to destroy his PFA awards hope
[image]
Even if someone told u Bruno will win PFA this year wouldn’t u denied it ?
Laggos
0
Pep beter make a move for Old Messi in January he can be a temporary solution for a few years to come
mmuthomi
0
Bruno after hearing KDB did nothing to destroy his PFA awards hope
elhafizdonb
1
I don't no why edarson always living the line
wayneogengo
0
David Silver and Aguero are what city Luck's..
fizzbizzie
1
city need a player like Fred in that midfield who can make tackle
which Fred...Fred is not different from Rodri.. they prefer to do the simple things.. Fernandinho was dynamic.. he could dribble , he could tackle, he picked the right passes most times and he never was afraid of risk passing too
fizzbizzie
2
I've said it severally that man city is not the same without Fernandinho.. and same reason I said their season will be tough cos they don't have the players to fit in the shoes..
yalcouye
1
he found some people who accept and listen to excuses in German or Italy or Spain they won't take it
Fipabeinr
0
What tackle Ederson had a bad game today the defence may have done better but he needed to stay on his line.
Ederson had a bad game? stop excuses
Banbdmptu
4
City got lost the day pep preferred rodri above fernandinho
jovimiro
5
Rodri is overrated, I always says old fernadinho is miles ahead of rodri
Handsome Mike
2
Lost without Arteta! Not Fernandinho!
Foubiopz
2
I agree
FootballGuru
0
city need a player like Fred in that midfield who can make tackle
What tackle Ederson had a bad game today the defence may have done better but he needed to stay on his line.
Fumclotz
5
city need a player like Fred in that midfield who can make tackle