England's World Cup squad received far fewer hateful messages than they were sent during last year's European Championship.
The Times have reported that there were 168 abusive social media posts - all of which were on Twitter - directed at players during the tournament in Qatar.
This compares to last year's European Championship, where there was around 3,000 alone in the hours after their penalty shootout loss to Italy in the final.
A lot of the abuse in 2021 was thrown at Bukayo Saka, Marcus Rashford and Jadon Sancho, who were deluged with racist messages after missing penalties in the final.
Eleven people were arrested after police examined 207 hateful messages and one teenager was sentenced to six weeks in jail after the abuse in 2021.
Over the last few weeks, messages towards the England squad have mostly been positive and hopeful.
However, Harry Kane, who missed a penalty in the quarter-final loss to France, was the most abused player in Qatar for the Three Lions.
There was 88 tweets directed towards the England captain, with Ben White next with 23 after he left the tournament early for personal reasons.
The final player to get more than 10 abusive tweets was Mason Mount on 11.
The research was carried out by HateLab, a monitoring group at Cardiff University which used artificial intelligence to monitor Twitter, Reddit, 4Chan and the messaging service Telegram for posts that target players with either racist, homophobic or transphobic content.
During the Euro 2020 tournament, HateLab is said to have detected 'tens of thousands of hateful tweets' peaking at '920 an hour' after the final.
Professor Matthew Williams, the director of HateLab, said: 'Compared with Euro 2020 we're seeing very little racist, anti-black communications targeting the players. For the most part, the hopeful posts, very positive posts, dwarfed the amount of very negative and hateful posts.
Williams said last year's prosecutions may have played a part in the reduction in hateful messages. While Twitter now recognises the use of certain emojis as racial abuse.
He did though add: 'I think part of the reason is, of course, there were no trigger events in the tournament, where a black player made a huge mistake.'
There was though some 'anti-LGBTQ' messages fuelled by the row over scrapped plans for Harry Kane to wear an armband in support of gay rights.
England captain Kane missed a crucial penalty as the Three Lions were knocked out by France in the quarter-finals with a 2-1 defeat.
Rashford and Saka, who missed penalties in last year's final, were England's joint highest scorers in Qatar with three goals apiece - while Sancho was left out of the squad after struggling for form at Manchester United.
vozdeklmnr
2
You phorking pigs; when it was a black man who missed the penalty, it was like hell on earth and now it's a white man, it's just water under the bridge...
EffLeo
0
LOL.. less abuse.. what an improvement. . people these days.. can only say negative things behind screens which most of them won't even dare to say if they are looking at the person face to face. what of a bunch of cowards.
quantized
1
Because it was not Saka who missed penalty this time around...
Zuzcelopuy
1
Simply put,A white guy missed the penalty
Gunners4ever❤
0
This is why. The blacks outshine the whites at the World Cup tournament.
[image]
This is just as bad as racism against blacks, f00l. If you want racism to end, then don't spread it around yourself.
Tipbcklmst
0
itz bcoz Saka played well..... imagine he was the one who hit that penalty in to the sky.....since it was Harry Kane.....the world is quite
Daaabkoy
1
England 🏴 are full of clowns 🤡
jahbimptu
1
Black lives matters
yonabckmor
2
because of kean is white, if that penalty missed by one of the black player the things is changed.
Jeremy21
2
This is why. The blacks outshine the whites at the World Cup tournament.
Lukcklmruz
0
They will receive fewer hate because the blacks performed than the whites.
hudbelmnop
2
This is because of the racist instincts in most whites. The hateful messages came as a series of penalty miss by the blacks in the final. This time around, a crucial penalty was missed by a white and fewer hateful messages hit the public. The writing is very clear on the wall
Sokdelosy
2
God wanted to show you that even white can miss the penalty
Sokdelosy
2
because it was not Saka who missed a penalty
KNlyer
1
white men all the way
Coolluck26
5
that's because kane missed
bohabdeopz
4
That is because Saka did not take the penalty. Had he taken land lost as did Kane...the racists knives would have been drawn!
fourthorty430
4
But why are they attacking Saka racially , and some of England fans telling him to go back to Nigeria . while nothing is said towards Harry Kane that lost a penalty..
Manuelm200
5
It's because Kane missed the pen but if it was someone like Raheem Sterling, he would be receiving death threats.But they say No room for Racism in football, what a joke.
Donbekosy
3
what do you expect when it was a white man this time around. I always told people that England and Italy are the two most racists country in the world.
joe1822play
3
because it was a white man who caused their downfall
bihaimsuy
1
Thank God the penalty was missed by Kane.
Towabostuz
3
Because the man who sent them home is white not black
GGMUSTAR
1
Because its Kane... If it was Saka🙆♀️🙆♂️
Ahhhh
Emmy619
3
Because it's a White man that Blow away the Penalty that knock them out.. Just imagine it was Rashford that Waste the Penalty.??🤔🤔
whytetouch
4
if we're being honest, the reason for the fewer Hateful post is because it wasn't a black man who missed the crucial penalty.
Et͟h͟e͟r͟t͟o͟n͟Midz
2
It is because the penalty was missed with a white guy.They don't abuse theirs if that penalty was from black players..........
Loceikoru
1
The English media is so dumb, this is only because the dude who missed the penalty is not black!!! their fans have no one target to direct their hate on
fakadensy
1
yea that's because the guy who missed the penalty this year isn't black
PaulLobee
2
Because its Kane... If it was Saka🙆♀️🙆♂️