After Lionel Messi's leaked contract further underlined just how unsustainable Barcelona's finances are, Sportsmail asks the big questions concerning the club captain's future.
Can they afford to keep him? Can they afford to let him go? And will bonds and a Buffon gesture help keep player and club together beyond the summer?
Messi can't have been happy to see the details of his contract all over El Mundo on Sunday. Does this increase the chances of him leaving?
Not really because if there was a leak from inside the club it came from people who are no longer in charge (former board) or who are only temporarily in charge (interim board). From March 7 the club will have a new president, it will be a new start.
And Joan Laporta is the favourite and he says he thinks Messi wants to stay? Would he know?
He spoke to him on Sunday and yes he says he has indications that Messi wants to stay. Barcelona still need to make him the right offer of course.
And with a short-term debt of €720m (£636m) there is no way they are going to be able to match his current deal.
Matching his current deal was never going to be an option anyway. He'll be 34 next June. You don't pay 34-year-old Messi what you pay 30-year-old Messi. Then with the pandemic massively reducing the club's revenue it was always clear that like every other mortal he was going to have to take a pay cut.
Barcelona's potential problem is that even a deal well below the current £122m guaranteed gross (and it's best to use the gross figure because that is what Barcelona have to pay albeit half to the tax man) will be hard to finance.
Hard to finance or impossible?
If the club get back to 2019's €840m annual revenue then maintaining his status as, at the very least, the club's top earner might not be impossible.
If travel and attendance at football matches is back to normal by September 2021, when in effect Messi would kick off his first season with the new contract, that becomes more feasible.
Plenty gets said about what it would cost to keep him. Losing him also comes with a price does it not?
That's exaclty the calcuation the new president will need to make. It's highly unlikely Messi will play another full season in Europe beyond the next World Cup (that appears to be his cut-off point for moving to the US) so the next two seasons will be his last.
From a commercial point of view they will be lucrative campaigns: his last ever Clasico, his last ever Champions League game for Barcelona, his last ever game at the Nou Camp, his last ever match in the Barcelona shirt. Sponsors will want a piece of that Messi farewell tour pie. The first-team shirt is up for renewal in 2022.
If Rakuten choose to sponsor it again they will be willing to pay considerably more if Messi's wearing the No 10 and in his last ever games to huge global audiences, than if he isn't. Diario Sport's front page said Messi had been responsible for €237m (£209m) of revenue in the last three years. The numbers can always be contested but it's clear the Barcelona brand is considerably more attractive with Messi than without him.
What plans do the presidential candidates have for reverting the club's financial crisis and making paying Messi more feasible?
The election favourite, Laporta, has spoken about the possibility of two types of bonds scheme that would raise immediate capital.
The first would target Barcelona fans and for their investment those buying the bonds (not strictly bonds in this sense but let's call them that) would be rewarded in kind.
The second scheme would be bonds in a more literal sense with members and non-members alike able to buy bonds repayable within the president's five-year term, with interest. A bond is not a share. In the case of a business going into administration those with bonds are bottom of the list when it comes to receiving any money for example.
This would however bring in private money to the club, but without compromising the club's member-ownership model. The second idea would have to be passed by the National Securities Market Commission before it could be used.
Could there also be a gesture from Messi? Maybe he'll pay for nothing for the last two years?
Yes and maybe when grounds reopen to spectators, supporters will be allowed in for free! It's true that when Juventus were relegated in Italy certain players such as Gianluigi Buffon and Alessandro Del Piero stuck around at great financial loss to help the team.
Messi would win politically if he did something similar. Regardless of whether he stays or goes he is due a €39m (£34m) loyalty payment on July 15. That could also be written off either way as a goodwill gesture.
Where does he go if he goes?
Remember how last summer, before it became clear Manchester City were the only club he was going to if he left, and Inter were touted as a possible destination? Well Inter haven't paid their players since June 2020. The point is everyone is in a similar situation.
PSG can't keep Neymar, Kylian Mbappe AND sign Messi. Madrid would love Messi to go to Paris on the understanding it could mean Mbappe comes there way but PSG may prefer the younger player.
Manchster City still look the most likely to be able to make it work with a longer deal that includes Messi moving to the US but one thing regarding his decision should not be overlooked.
Messi made it clear last summer his family were delighted they could stay where they were so if he does move in the summer it will be against their wishes. Of course if Barcelona flat out can't afford him then the Messi clan will have to start packing regardless.
wahbclpstu
0
Messi Deserved every penni he is getting because he is the greatest player of all time, and also he makes Barcelona great all these past 10yrs, so let’s hater keep hating nobody cares he work for it he play football to be paid that’s the reason he left Argentina at the age of 13yrs so let him be and enjoy let Barcelona fans stop worrying. As Jose say Messi is like a porn everyone likes it but deny him in public because of his Greatness😃😃😀
mk9drakku
0
Just picture Cristiano Ronaldo & Lionel Messi in JUVENTUS! WOW
It can never and will never happen
laheinpu
3
It's kinda funny 🤣 If he stays people (Haters) will say he is staying for money, if he leaves than people will say he didn't love his club, he loves money so he wants to go in a club where he gets more money. Either way Messi will have to face backlash from everyone
MessiDeBrune
1
messi should stop hiding from his responsibilities & should start scoring goals he should enter in the penalty box consistently to score He is holding back nowdays to prevent himself from responsibilities
Cemdemu
0
Broke ass Barca .Your 'God' has sucked you dry
He makes 300mllion a year for Barca that’s more than a third of their income
LM10_rockstar
0
and by the way no team will be willing to pay somebody 500,000 million during this pandemic.
If it wasn't for El Mundo would we have even figure out that Barcelona pay him 555 million, so never underrate any team. And another thing is that Messi earns more for his club through sponsors and marketing. So if you're a club and now you know that Messi collects half of what he earns, won't you go for it
Heet10
0
Yes they can if the team performance is good Messi will stay as he said he does not play for money he will be in a team where he feels he is value able and respected
Willygeez
0
so if he decides not to take 70% or more salary cut why will you call him selfish, there are other teams who would pay him better than Barcelona and also fight for champions league, but he still decides to give them another chance only if they can. Do you think Messi will leave Barcelona if they win champions league leave? No.
and by the way no team will be willing to pay somebody 500,000 million during this pandemic.
LM10_rockstar
0
Dude that happened in march last year. Have done my research and you need you learn to understand things before commenting 🤦🏾♂️.
so if he decides not to take 70% or more salary cut why will you call him selfish, there are other teams who would pay him better than Barcelona and also fight for champions league, but he still decides to give them another chance only if they can. Do you think Messi will leave Barcelona if they win champions league leave? No.
Vendiknprt
0
The fact is that Messi is the only pig player in Barcelona currently and as for Madrid stars their are big names there still after Ronaldo’s departure though the lost just few of their sponsors. So as to say, it’s a different situation
Do you know the reason why Barcelona are not interested in back up international brands that are marketable to support Messi ? From current information I think it is because they have over priced Messi beyond market price ( Barcelona capabilities). So their financial capacity couldn't accommodate other marketable brands (stars)like Neymar or mbappe. Pls I don't want this discussion to be emotional rather than business minded. while Mr Perez was able to balance the book with and without Ronaldo barca board under mind Barcelona values to the detriment of Messi, thus playing to Messi agent hands. Today the challenges is complex because should Messi leave in June barca will be mentally phycologically down. That means barca going back to earliest president fears again.Unfortunately barca may loose because Messi is getting older with expensive unaffordable salary plus others incentives packages. My question is when will the circle end ? when will the brand Barcelona become bigger than its players? Even laporta will still appeal to Messi to stay. please I need objection answers.
Willygeez
0
Dude he agreed to 70% salary cut, and this makes him the most unselfish player. So search before you post
Dude that happened in march last year. Have done my research and you need you learn to understand things before commenting 🤦🏾♂️.
LM10_rockstar
0
It's basically simple the club can't pay him anymore and if he still demands for more to stay then the guy is more than selfish. Legends come and go and this will be goodbye.
Dude he agreed to 70% salary cut, and this makes him the most unselfish player. So search before you post
simzer
0
Thank you for your analysis but I am yet to read deep analysis with facts figures on why Messi will stay rather most responses are emotionally on why Messi should stay. Real Madrid sold Ronaldo yet they still have sponsors so I don't share the believe that should Messi leave sponsors will desert Barcelona completely. I think the brand Barcelona is an international imagine. Agree Barcelona without Messi will require re-branding, but without Ronaldo Real Madrid is still Real Madrid. My question is will Barcelona die without Messi ?
i think Madrid and especially Perez is really good at handling the business side of a club, messi could be leaving for free while Ronaldo was sold and any shotfalls from sponsors and everything was probably taken care of at least for some months until they could find a way of dealing with the departure of Ronaldo
ManUnited-Red
1
To sell him it had to be right now cuz on summer time he's free to sign with tf he wants.
yeah, true bro
XxKingCR7xX
1
Barca need to sell Messi this season
To sell him it had to be right now cuz on summer time he's free to sign with tf he wants.
nuucilmpst
0
Broke ass Barca .Your 'God' has sucked you dry
XxKingCR7xX
0
this is not an important question at the moment bcos messi is not at his best. I won't mind if he end up in China MSL
There's no way he going to China. PSG, Man City, Barcelona or an Argentinian team but this last one I see him more when he retires. I think he's going to PSG cuz they got a Argentinian coach and neymar will renew his contract
raadilrs
0
Barcelona is bankrupt. hahaha. at Chelsea money is never a problem our problem is how to spend it.
lbcrna
0
this is not an important question at the moment bcos messi is not at his best. I won't mind if he end up in China MSL
Willygeez
1
It's basically simple the club can't pay him anymore and if he still demands for more to stay then the guy is more than selfish. Legends come and go and this will be goodbye.
nandlnprt
0
8552
Ghsarkarzadeh
1
Just picture Cristiano Ronaldo & Lionel Messi in JUVENTUS! WOW
cupaclryz
0
Thank you for your analysis but I am yet to read deep analysis with facts figures on why Messi will stay rather most responses are emotionally on why Messi should stay. Real Madrid sold Ronaldo yet they still have sponsors so I don't share the believe that should Messi leave sponsors will desert Barcelona completely. I think the brand Barcelona is an international imagine. Agree Barcelona without Messi will require re-branding, but without Ronaldo Real Madrid is still Real Madrid. My question is will Barcelona die without Messi ?
The fact is that Messi is the only pig player in Barcelona currently and as for Madrid stars their are big names there still after Ronaldo’s departure though the lost just few of their sponsors. So as to say, it’s a different situation
Drogon111
0
If single Barca fans collect £2, it will be of enough to pay his couple years of salary...!
BT_CR7
2
Happy Birthday CR7...♥️🎂😘
ManUnited-Red
1
sell ? he is leaving for free dude.
same thing bro
JohnRahul
2
Barca need to sell Messi this season
sell ? he is leaving for free dude.
Vendiknprt
2
Thank you for your analysis but I am yet to read deep analysis with facts figures on why Messi will stay rather most responses are emotionally on why Messi should stay. Real Madrid sold Ronaldo yet they still have sponsors so I don't share the believe that should Messi leave sponsors will desert Barcelona completely. I think the brand Barcelona is an international imagine. Agree Barcelona without Messi will require re-branding, but without Ronaldo Real Madrid is still Real Madrid. My question is will Barcelona die without Messi ?
Ruzacpsy
0
good luck Barcelona God help us
Fifbro11
2
I don't think leaving is the right thing to do at this moment Messi should stick around and help the team regain it efficiency
[image]
True
KaiSanny
0
yes. if he takes a pay cut. I think he wants to stay coz the team is in red hot form. we can win many titles next season
I don't think the team is in possession to win any titles and how much Messi should pay cut then barca can effort him?
baller69
0
actually barca can't afford messi to leave...messi makes half of barcelona entire money they will actually go bankrupt if messi leaves ...messi already accepted 70% pay cut and he would even accept 100% paycut but still media will try to blame messi anyway
well said. and I hope he retires at barca. he'll be a god for masia kids. starting at barca and ending at barca as the god of football. wow. just messi things
baller69
2
yes. if he takes a pay cut. I think he wants to stay coz the team is in red hot form. we can win many titles next season
Syd007
0
Happy birthday GOAT
[image]
❤️
zuzaanlimbu123
0
i was barca fan..... until koeman came and setien.... had many reasons to hate them...
Nindimnpr
2
Busy writing nonsense as if they have all financial records for Barcelona
imme03
0
Happy birthday GOAT
[image]
One more year to go
ManUnited-Red
0
Happy birthday GOAT
[image]
noooo, I don't want to see goat retire 😭😭😭
ManUnited-Red
3
Barca need to sell Messi this season
Thuglife42
2
Messi must leave Barcelona in the summer, Barcelona dont have any respect for Messi, Barcelona dont deserve a talent like Messi, Messi contract should never been leaked .
D10S_LM10
5
Barcelona can afford to keep him but he won't stay. It's as simple as that and we all know the reason.
MacThePublisher
1
Messi will STAY if he loves Barcelona!
4342deeni
3
I don't think leaving is the right thing to do at this moment Messi should stick around and help the team regain it efficiency
Hiydknsy
2
After Messi had broken Pele's World Record of MOST GOALS for a single Club. I don't care he leaves or not. Perhaps I will be appreciative to Messi if he stays Authentic G.O.A.T not the fake one because he is
👉One of the Greatest Goalscorers Ever
👉Most Ballon Dors in History
👉 Most Assists in Football History
👉Greatest Playmaker in History
👉Greatest Dribbler in History
@ Antithesis he is Most Tapin Dor in History
@ Most Player who stands in the penalty to wait for that tapin. If you know you know I mean Dubai D'OR
samir-rm
2
Happy birthday GOAT
Raaz2021
1
In My opinion ...when club or players are in bad conditions .. they must cooperate each other and help each other...
AntoJaison
1
unfortunately, more than trophies, legend & inspiration, barca board sees Messi as money now
ameeremkayy
0
Reasons why Barca should let messi leave: ....1.They will save the salary weight they pay over him 2. They will have enough money to make their financial problems balance with his transfer fee. 3.Their Squad players will be able to compete to become the clubs new Messi. Reasons why Barca shouldn't let Messi leave: ....1.They will loose some of their sponsors. 2.They will miss a great player like no other. 3. They will miss the spot as the best team in the world. 4. Their league will be less joy to watch. . But what ever will be decided at the end, whether Messi leaves or not. Barca will forever be barca Forca Barca
LM10DGOAT
1
When the pandemic ends, everything will be fine
dunablrt
1
actually barca can't afford messi to leave...messi makes half of barcelona entire money they will actually go bankrupt if messi leaves ...messi already accepted 70% pay cut and he would even accept 100% paycut but still media will try to blame messi anyway