Who is the best Liverpool striker you've ever seen?
It's a debate that can run long into the night for any fan who has watched the Kop's electrifying forwards over the years, a tradition stretching throughout the 20th century until the present day involving names who have set a city on fire.
Ian Ladyman took on the task of naming the best five Reds forwards he's ever seen - and it's a mix of old blood with modern names.
Mo Salah was, unsurprisingly, the only player out of their current crop to make the list as the others still have some way to go to catch the all-time greats.
Chris Sutton, Ladyman's sidekick on It's All Kicking Off, was surprised at one major omission - as well as his pick for number one.
In fifth place for Ladyman was Kevin Keegan, who scored 100 goals across six seasons and helped Liverpool to their first European Cup as well as three First Division titles.
Ladyman's fourth-choice pick was Luis Suarez, who bagged 82 goals in a prolific three-and-a-half years on Merseyside and numerous individual awards.
The bronze medallist in this intense competition was Ian Rush, Liverpool's all-time top scorer with 346 goals and 20 trophies to his name from a stunning career at Anfield.
Sutton was surprised that Rush, whose most formidable season saw him score 47 goals, did not reach top spot.
Ahead of him was Kenny Dalglish, who scored 172 times for the club after joining from Celtic and helped to define their dominance in Europe in the late 1970s and 1980s.
But top spot was reserved for Salah, who has 204 Liverpool goals to his name and 88 assists, dazzling fans with his combination of skill, speed, strength, and deadly finishing, seeming to create goals out of the impossible.
'He's such a superb passer of the ball now, Salah, in a way that he didn't used to be,' Ladyman said.
'The number of chances that he sets up for dear old Darren Nunez is quite extraordinary. If Nunez ever starts to convert any of them then Liverpool really will be in business. So anyway on the back of that I went on to say that I thought Salah probably is the greatest Liverpool striker that I've ever seen play.'
Sutton couldn't help but feel that Rush was perhaps more deserving of the highest gong, just because of his ridiculous number of goals compared to the competition.
He added: 'Robbie Fowler, my era, played in an era of many great English strikers. Shearer was a phenomenal finisher. Would it be fair to say though, Robbie Fowler was the most natural finisher? I thought, I'm surprised you haven't got him in there somewhere. I think he had a hundred more goals than Kevin Keegan, albeit Keegan was a great player.'
Ladyman said: 'Yeah, I think the one that I wrestled over was Keegan-Fowler. I know Michael Owen as well, you could talk about.
'But Keegan-Fowler was the one that I thought about. I just thought that Kevin was, he played for Liverpool in such a transformative era, that time when they were kind of transitioning through from Shankly through to Paisley and starting to win the big trophies, scored a goal in the FA Cup final when they beat New Castle, won the penalty in Rome when they beat Borussia Monchengladbach to win the first European Cup final in 1977 and then went on and left and went on to become European Footballer of the Year at Hamburg etcetra.
'I just thought for what Keegan did at that time and what he represented and what Liverpool achieved when he was with them. That was what just gave him the edge over Fowler, who was, as you say, an absolutely extraordinary finisher.
'And I think had it not been for a couple of injuries, Robbie would have scored even more goals than he did for Liverpool before he moved on to Man City and Leeds and people like that. Anyway, that's my list.'